Trans Mountain was built to give Canadian oil a second customer. Two and a half years after the expansion opened, it has one: in 2026 Canada is shipping 533,000 b/d of crude outside the United States, more than it sends to the US Gulf Coast. Verified

The world has changed around the pipe. A trade war, a war in the Gulf and Venezuela’s return to the US market have made Canada’s only non-US outlet its most strategic energy asset. But the pipe is full, freight is at records, and the discount on Canadian heavy oil is the widest since 2018. We set out what the pivot earned, who now keeps the value, and our view of the discount to 2030.

In 60 seconds

  • The pivot happened. Exports outside the US rose from 131 kb/d in 2023 to 533 kb/d in 2026, while the US Gulf Coast fell from 757 to 439 kb/d. The US share of Canada’s crude exports fell from 97% to 88%.
  • It paid. The WCS discount fell from US$18.67 in 2023 to US$11.76 in 2025: about US$8.8bn a year more for Canada’s heavy oil, on our estimate.
  • Three forces widened it again. Full pipes, record freight that closed the Gulf Coast re-export route, and Venezuelan heavy back in the Gulf. WCS traded US$25–30 below WTI in late October; Alberta’s budget assumed US$13.
  • Venezuela rotated the trade. US imports of Venezuelan crude rose from 0.2 to 0.7 mb/d this year, and Venezuela sent none to China. Venezuelan heavy goes north; Canadian heavy goes west.
  • Freight decides who keeps the value. Full Aframax loads from 2027 save about US$1.6 a barrel. Loading VLCCs at Pacific Link’s terminal would save about US$3.2 more, about US$1.2bn a year.
  • Our view. US$18–22 in 2027 and US$17–21 in 2028; back to US$12–15 only if Prairie Connector is built. Six dated calls are in Section VIII.

Canada Now Ships More Crude Overseas Than to the US Gulf Coast

The expansion opened in May 2024 and tripled Trans Mountain’s capacity to 890 kb/d. Verified In the fourth quarter of 2025 it delivered a record 807 kb/d: 504 kb/d to the Westridge Marine Terminal, 203 kb/d by pipeline to refineries in Washington State and 100 kb/d within BC. Verified Only the Westridge share can reach Asia.

Fig. 1Where Trans Mountain’s barrels go
Trans Mountain deliveries by outlet, Q4 2025, kb/d; tanker counts to October 2026
What it shows → Trans Mountain shipped a record 807 kb/d in Q4 2025: 504 kb/d to tankers at Westridge, 203 kb/d to Washington State refineries and 100 kb/d within BC.
How to read it → Read left to right: the dark block is total deliveries; each band is one outlet, drawn to scale. The box on the right counts tankers loaded at Westridge since May 2024.
Why it matters → Only the Westridge share can reach Asia, and its dock is Aframax-only. That is the bottleneck behind the rest of this article.
Trans Mountain deliveries, Q4 2025 average, thousand barrels a day (kb/d)807kb/d shipped91% of capacity504 kb/dWestridge Marine Terminaltankers to Asia and the US West Coast203 kb/dWashington State refineriesby pipeline (Puget Sound)100 kb/dBC delivery pointsBurnaby refinery and local terminalsAT WESTRIDGE691tankers loaded, May 2024 to Oct 2026455of them bound for Asia (66%)~50%of marine volumes to China630 kb/ddock capacity, Aframax onlyDeliveries are Q4 2025 averages; tanker counts to 21 October 2026.
Sources: Trans Mountain, Q4 and full-year 2025 results (deliveries); S&P Global, 21 Oct 2026 (vessels); RBC Capital Markets via The Logic, 17 Aug 2026 (China share); CER Market Snapshot, Sep 2025 (dock capacity).

The regulator’s export data show how far the map has moved. Canadian crude exports outside the US averaged 131 kb/d in 2023, 445 kb/d in 2025 and 533 kb/d in January–August 2026. Exports to the US Gulf Coast fell from 757 to 439 kb/d over the same period, while the Midwest rose from 2,447 to 2,780 kb/d and the US West Coast from 286 to 394 kb/d. Verified Trans Mountain did not just add a customer; it took barrels away from the Gulf Coast. Interpretation

Fig. 2The crossover: overseas exports pass the US Gulf Coast
Canadian crude exports by destination, kb/d, 2019–2026
What it shows → Canada now ships more crude outside the US (533 kb/d) than to the US Gulf Coast (439 kb/d, down from 757 in 2023).
How to read it → Each line is Canadian crude exports to one destination, in thousand barrels a day. The shaded bar marks the expansion opening in May 2024; 2026 covers January to August.
Why it matters → Trans Mountain did not just add Asia. It pulled barrels away from the Gulf Coast, so US refiners there now compete with Asian buyers for Canadian heavy oil.
Canadian crude exports, kb/d (annual average; 2026 = January to August)015030045060075090020192020202120222023202420252026*Expansion opens, May 2024US Gulf Coast439 kb/dOutside the US (mostly Asia)533 kb/dUS West Coast394 kb/d757131Confidential months excluded. 2024 non-US is June–December. Pre-2024 non-US was mostly Atlantic offshore crude.
Source: Canada Energy Regulator, crude oil exports by destination (monthly open data, to August 2026). Insight Stream annual averages.

Asia takes most of what reaches the coast. Of 691 tankers loaded at Westridge to 21 October, 455 went to Asia. Reported China has taken nearly half of marine volumes since 2024, according to RBC’s tracking, and Asia took nearly 77% of the crude exported from Vancouver in the first seven months of 2026, up from about 51% in 2024. Reported Korean refiners have stepped up: South Korea aims to import up to 16 million barrels of Canadian crude in 2026, more than triple 2025. Reported In July Japan’s largest refiner bought its first Canadian cargo since 2025. Reported But concentration is real: one Chinese refiner, Zhejiang Petroleum & Chemical, bought about 178 kb/d in the first eight months of 2026, up 36% on 2025. Reported That is roughly a third of Westridge loadings. Estimate

Table 1The scoreboard: before the expansion, after it, and now
Measure202320252026
Crude exports outside the US, kb/d131445533 (Jan–Aug)
Crude exports to the US Gulf Coast, kb/d757563439 (Jan–Aug)
Crude exports to the US Midwest, kb/d2,4472,6492,780 (Jan–Aug)
WTI minus WCS, US$ per barrel18.6711.7615.69 (Jan–Sep); 24.80–29.75 daily in Oct
Trans Mountain throughput, kb/dLegacy line only761 (86% full)840 in Q2 (94%); 98% in July
Heavy toll to Westridge, C$ per barrel4.29–4.3310.84–13.18 firm; 14.40 spot10.84–13.18 firm; 14.06 spot
Sources: CER crude exports by destination and Trans Mountain tolls (open data); Government of Alberta BVM components and US EIA (WTI–WCS); Reuters via BOE Report (October daily settlements); Trans Mountain results.

A Dividend of About US$9 Billion a Year

The clearest gain is in the price. The discount of Western Canadian Select to WTI averaged about US$18.70 in the eight months before the expansion and about US$12.00 in the year after it, on the regulator’s figures. Verified On annual averages it went from US$18.67 in 2023 to US$15.56 in 2024 and US$11.76 in 2025. Verified

Fig. 3The discount fell when the pipe opened, and rose when it filled
WTI minus WCS, US$ per barrel, monthly, January 2019 to September 2026, with October daily range
What it shows → The WCS discount fell from about US$18.70 before the expansion to about US$12 after it. It widened again in 2026, and daily settlements in October ran from US$24.80 to US$29.75.
How to read it → The line is the monthly gap between WTI and Western Canadian Select, in US$ per barrel; higher means cheaper Canadian oil. Coloured bars show the regulator's before and after averages; the red bar spans October's daily settlements.
Why it matters → The discount is the scoreboard for export capacity. When pipes have room it narrows; when they fill, or freight closes other outlets, it widens.
Discount of Western Canadian Select to WTI, US$ per barrel (monthly average; higher = cheaper Canadian oil)$0$5$10$15$20$25$3020192020202120222023202420252026$18.70 before$12.00 afterExpansion opensPipe fullOctober 2026, daily:US$24.80 to 29.75Monthly averages to September 2026. The red bar spans daily settlements reported between 5 and 30 October.
Sources: Government of Alberta, Bitumen Valuation Methodology components (WCS); US EIA (WTI); CER Market Snapshot, Sep 2025 (before and after averages); CalRock via Reuters and BOE Report, 5–30 Oct 2026 (daily settlements).

On about 3.5 mb/d of WCS-priced heavy oil, each US$1 a barrel is worth about US$1.28bn a year. Against 2023, the narrower discount was worth about US$4.0bn in 2024 and US$8.8bn in 2025, roughly C$12bn. Estimate Not all of that is Trans Mountain: Mexican decline and Venezuelan sanctions also tightened heavy oil, but the timing is hard to miss. Interpretation

The discount moves fast. Monthly averages ranged from US$11.16 to US$18.99 over the past 14 months, and daily settlements in October ran from US$24.80 to US$29.75, well above the September average of US$16.94. Verified A single day is a poor basis for a year, so we value the discount on annual averages and show recent trading only as full-year scenarios. If October’s levels held for a year, Canadian heavy oil would earn about US$11bn less than in 2023 and about US$20bn less than in 2025. Estimate

Fig. 4The dividend, and what a wide discount would cost
Annual value of the change in the WCS discount against 2023, US$ billion, with full-year scenarios
What it shows → Against 2023, the narrower discount was worth about US$8.8bn in 2025. If October's trading level held for a full year, it would cost about US$10.7bn against 2023.
How to read it → Solid bars are annual averages of the change in the discount since 2023, multiplied by about 3.5 mb/d of WCS-priced heavy oil. Dashed bars hold one level for a full year: scenarios, not forecasts.
Why it matters → A single day is not a year, but the scenarios show the stakes: each US$1 a barrel is worth about US$1.3bn a year to Canadian producers.
Value of the change in the discount against 2023, US$ billion a year (~3.5 mb/d of WCS-priced heavy oil; US$1.28bn per US$1)SCENARIOS: IF THE DISCOUNT HELD AT THIS LEVEL FOR A FULL YEAR2024actual average US$15.56+US$4.0bn2025actual average US$11.76+US$8.8bn2026, Jan–Sepactual average US$15.69+US$3.8bnIf US$13 for a yearAlberta budget assumption+US$7.3bnIf US$20 for a yearour central view for 2027−US$1.7bnIf US$27 for a yearOctober–November trading−US$10.7bngain vs 2023 →← loss vs 2023Insight Stream estimate: (2023 average of US$18.67 minus each level) × 3.5 mb/d × 365. Solid bars are annual averages; dashed bars are scenarios, not forecasts of a single day.
Insight Stream estimate. Method: (2023 average of US$18.67 minus each level) × 3.5 mb/d × 365. Scenarios hold one level for a full year.

Three Forces Widened the Discount at Once

The pipes are full. Trans Mountain reached 98% of capacity in July and was apportioned by a record 7% in October. Enbridge’s Mainline cleared apportionment in September for the first time this year, then posted 16% on heavy crude and 19% on light for November. Reported

Freight shut the back door. With the Iran war pushing tanker rates to records, shipping Canadian heavy out of the Gulf Coast became uneconomic, and the WCS discount at Houston passed its October 2022 record of US$20.60. Reported At Hardisty, WCS settled US$24.80 below WTI on 5 October and US$29.75 on 30 October, the widest since 2018. Reported

Venezuela is back in the Gulf (Section IV). Commodity Context’s Rory Johnston argues the latest widening has nothing to do with pipeline capacity. Reported We see both: freight and Venezuela explain the timing, and full pipes explain why Alberta has no escape valve. Interpretation

The arithmetic will not ease soon. S&P Global CERA expects Canadian crude output to rise from 5.5 mb/d in 2026 to 5.8 mb/d in 2027 and 6.0 mb/d in 2028. Reported The new pipe that is certain adds about 480 kb/d by the end of 2028; Prairie Connector would add 465 kb/d at the end of 2028, but only if it is sanctioned in mid-2027. Reported Until then, rail carries the marginal barrel. Interpretation

Fig. 52027 is the tight year
New export pipe versus new crude supply, cumulative from the end of 2025, kb/d
What it shows → New supply of about 500 kb/d by 2028 roughly matches the new pipe that is certain (480 kb/d). Prairie Connector, if sanctioned, adds 465 kb/d at the end of 2028.
How to read it → Bars stack new export pipe by the year it opens, counted from the end of 2025. The red dashed line is S&P Global CERA's forecast growth in Canadian crude output.
Why it matters → 2027 is the tight year. Until new pipe opens, rail sets the price of the marginal barrel, and the discount reflects it.
Cumulative additions from end-2025, kb/d02004006008001000Express-Platte302026Express-PlatteEnbridge Mainline ph. 1Trans Mountain DRA2702027Express-PlatteEnbridge Mainline ph. 1Trans Mountain DRATrans Mountain MOPPrairie Connector (if sanctioned)9452028+300+500New crude supply (CERA), red dashesExpress-Platte expansionEnbridge Mainline, phase 1Trans Mountain drag reducerTrans Mountain optimizationPrairie Connector, if sanctionedWithout Prairie Connector,new pipe (480) roughlymatches new supply (500)by 2028, with no slack.Pipe volumes are blended crude; supply counts crude and condensate. Prairie Connector needs a mid-2027 FID.
Sources: S&P Global CERA via S&P Global, 21 Oct 2026 (supply); Trans Mountain fact sheet, Jul 2026; Enbridge; South Bow; Article 52.

Most of the 480 kb/d comes from working existing steel harder. A drag-reducing agent is a polymer injected into the oil that cuts friction, so the same pumps push more barrels; more pumping does the rest. Reported Optimization is the cheapest capacity in the system, and it runs out in 2028. Interpretation

Table 2Optimization first: where the next 480 kb/d comes from
ProjectAddsWhenHow
Express-Platte expansion30 kb/d2026More capacity on an existing line
Enbridge Mainline optimization, phase 1150 kb/d2027Upgrades on the existing Mainline system
Trans Mountain drag-reducing agent90 kb/dEarly 2027A polymer added to the oil cuts friction, so the same pumps move more
Second Narrows dredgingA third more per tankerQ1 2027A deeper channel lets Aframaxes leave Westridge full, not 75% loaded
Trans Mountain mainline optimization210 kb/dLate 2028More pumping on the expanded line; system to about 1.19 mb/d
Total new pipe480 kb/dBy end-2028Against about 500 kb/d of new supply (S&P Global CERA)
Sources: Trans Mountain fact sheet (Jul 2026) and Q2 2026 results; Enbridge; South Bow; S&P Global (21 Oct 2026). Prairie Connector (465 kb/d, if sanctioned) is new pipe and is not counted.

Filled with diluted bitumen, 480 kb/d of new pipe needs up to about 145 kb/d of diluent. Estimate Article 52’s diluent forecast counted Trans Mountain’s optimization, up to 420 kb/d including the Puget Sound line, as one step in 2030; the company now plans 300 kb/d of it in 2027–28. Re-running our model with that timing adds about 20 kb/d to Alberta’s diluent shortfall in 2028 and 10 kb/d in 2029: the squeeze arrives on the same timeline, slightly deeper. Estimate


Three Shocks Made One Pipe Strategic

A trade war. Washington put a 10% tariff on most Canadian goods in July and 50% tariffs on others in August, but neither targets crude: goods that meet USMCA rules are exempt, and energy is not among the 50% goods. Reported It also declined to renew USMCA, which now expires in 2036 unless renewed. Reported Crude is exempt because US refiners need it. Trans Mountain lets Canada say the same about Asia, and Ottawa’s goal is to double non-US exports within a decade. Reported

A war in the Gulf. The Iran war cut China’s seaborne crude imports to about 7 mb/d in July, against about 10 mb/d before it. Reported Chinese refiners went looking for heavy sour replacements: Cold Lake traded US$3–4 above Brent delivered to Shandong in early September, and one cargo sold at US$3.70 above Brent for October–November delivery. Reported A route to Asia that passes no chokepoint has become worth paying for (Article 51). Interpretation

Venezuela’s return. After the capture of Nicolás Maduro in January, Washington eased restrictions on Venezuelan oil. US imports of Venezuelan crude rose from about 200 kb/d at the start of 2026 to 701 kb/d in July, the most since 2017, and 655 kb/d in August. Verified In 2025 most Venezuelan crude went to China; in 2026 none has. Reported The heavy oil trade has rotated: Venezuelan barrels go north to Gulf Coast refiners built for them, and Canadian barrels go west to the Chinese refiners Venezuela used to supply. Interpretation For Canada the lesson is blunt: the Gulf Coast is no longer a reliable home for growth barrels, and the Pacific is where the new buyers are. Interpretation

Fig. 6One pipe, eight markets
What a full Trans Mountain moves, in one number each
What it shows → A full Trans Mountain moves eight markets at once, from the heavy oil price and Asian demand to US refiners, diluent, Alberta's budget, shipping and the next pipes.
How to read it → The dark centre tile is Trans Mountain today. Each tile around it is one market, with the one number that shows the effect. Red tiles cost Canada, green tiles help, grey tiles are context to watch.
Why it matters → Canada's energy system is one system. The discount, the diluent bill, freight and the next pipe are the same problem seen from different sides.
HEAVY OIL PRICEUS$15.7WCS discount, 2026 average to Sepvs US$11.8 in 2025; US$25–30 in late OctASIA77%of Vancouver crude exports went to AsiaJan–Jul 2026, up from 51% in 2024TRADE POLICY64%of US crude imports came from Canadain 2025; crude is spared US tariffsDILUENT~145 kb/dmore diluent for 480 kb/d of new pipemuch of it imported from the USTRANS MOUNTAIN TODAY890 kb/d98% full in Julyrecord 7% apportioned in OctoberUS REFINERS+334 / −318kb/d of Canadian crude, 2023 to 2026Midwest up; Gulf down as Venezuela returnsALBERTA’S BUDGETUS$13discount assumed for 2026–272026 runs above it; US$1 ≈ US$1.3bn/yrSHIPPINGUS$1.6–3.2a barrel saved by full Aframaxes (2027)and by VLCCs at Roberts Bank (2030s)NEXT PIPES+480 kb/dof new pipe by end-2028vs +500 kb/d supply; Pacific Link 2032–34Costs CanadaHelps CanadaContext to watchFigures as cited in the article. Diluent at a 30% blend; shipping savings are Insight Stream estimates at 2024 freight rates.
Sources: CER, US EIA, Congressional Research Service, Al Jazeera citing Kpler, Trans Mountain and Government of Alberta, as cited in the article. Diluent at a 30% blend; shipping savings are Insight Stream estimates.

The links run both ways. Every barrel of diluted bitumen loaded at Westridge carries about 0.3 barrels of diluent, sold to Asia at a heavy crude price and replaced in Alberta at a light oil price, much of it from the US Midwest (Article 52). Estimate The condensate Alberta does produce comes largely from liquids-rich Montney and Duvernay gas wells, whose pace depends on LNG demand from LNG Canada’s second phase and Ksi Lisims. Interpretation And projects deducted C$29.7 billion of diluent costs in 2025 before royalties, so a wider discount and dearer diluent both cut the Crown’s take. Estimate Oil, gas, condensate and the provincial budget are one balance sheet. Interpretation


What Canada’s Pivot Means South of the Border

The United States is the other side of every number here. Canada supplied 64% of US crude imports in 2025, up from 41% in 2015. Reported Three US regions feel the pivot in different ways.

The Midwest is more dependent than ever. Canadian exports to the Midwest averaged 2,780 kb/d in January–August 2026, 334 kb/d more than in 2023, and its refiners processed about 2.92 mb/d of Canadian crude in the first half. Verified They buy at prices tied to Hardisty, so a wider discount is largely a transfer from Alberta to them, and to whoever holds rail and pipe space. On averages to September, that transfer is already about US$5bn a year more than in 2025; at our 2027 central view it would be about US$11bn. Estimate

The Gulf Coast has Venezuela. Exports to the Gulf Coast fell 318 kb/d between 2023 and 2026; Gulf refiners processed about 337 kb/d of Canadian crude in the first half of 2026, against 526 kb/d in 2024. Reported Enbridge’s Houston Oil Terminal, opened in July, gives Canadian barrels on the Gulf an export route, but at today’s freight rates few can use it. Interpretation

The West Coast is buying more. Exports to the US West Coast rose from 286 to 394 kb/d. Verified About 200 kb/d goes by pipe to Washington State refineries; on our arithmetic, most of the rest goes by tanker to California, which closed 284 kb/d of refining, 17% of its capacity, with Phillips 66’s Los Angeles refinery in October 2025 and Valero’s Benicia plant in April 2026. Estimate For Washington, a full Trans Mountain is mostly good news: Midwest refiners get cheaper heavy oil, Gulf refiners have Venezuela, and Canada still sends 88% of its crude exports to the United States. Interpretation


Freight Decides Who Keeps the Asian Premium

Westridge sits behind the Second Narrows in Burrard Inlet and loads only Aframaxes, about 75% full: Japan’s July cargo carried 559,070 barrels against a full load of about 750,000. Reported In normal markets it paid to sail those Aframaxes to the lightering zone off California and move the oil onto very large crude carriers (VLCCs), which carry about 2 million barrels. In June 2024 Argus put that route at US$4.36 a barrel to China, against US$6.32 for a direct Aframax, and 78% of Asian cargoes used it. Reported

The Iran war flipped that. VLCC rates hit records, a direct Aframax voyage fell to about 54% of the cost of the transfer route, and by August no Asian cargo was transferred. Reported Platts assessed a Vancouver–China Aframax at about US$3.1 million a voyage in August, about US$5.70 a barrel, before a record US$7.5 million on 10 September. Reported

Fig. 7What it costs to ship a barrel to China, by route
Freight from Vancouver to China, US$ per barrel, at normal and war-time VLCC rates
What it shows → Before the war, moving oil onto VLCCs off California saved about US$2 a barrel against a 75%-loaded direct Aframax. War-time VLCC rates reversed that, so every Asian cargo now sails direct.
How to read it → Each bar is the freight cost per barrel from Vancouver to China by route. The top panel uses June 2024 rates, the bottom August 2026 rates. Solid bars are reported; dashed bars are our estimates.
Why it matters → Full Aframax loads from 2027 save about US$1.6 a barrel; VLCCs at Pacific Link's Roberts Bank terminal would save about US$3.2 more. Freight is the core of Pacific Link's case.
Freight cost to deliver a barrel of Canadian heavy crude from Vancouver to China, US$ per barrelAT JUNE 2024 RATES: NORMAL VLCC MARKETDirect Aframax, 75% loadedArgus, 13 Jun 2024$6.32Aframax to California, then a VLCCArgus, incl. ship-to-ship transfer$4.36Direct Aframax, full (after dredging)our estimate$4.60California transfer with full Aframaxesour estimate$3.46VLCC direct from Roberts Bank (Pacific Link)our estimate; in service 2032–34$1.38AT AUGUST 2026 RATES: WAR-TIME VLCC MARKETDirect Aframax, 75% loadedPlatts US$3.1m lump sum, ~544k bbl$5.70Aframax to California, then a VLCCArgus: direct costs 54% of this route$10.56Direct Aframax, full (after dredging)our estimate$4.13WHAT IT SAVESDredging (full Aframaxes): ~US$1.6–1.7 a barrel on direct voyages, about US$0.3bn a year on 500 kb/d.VLCC loading at Roberts Bank vs a full Aframax: ~US$3.2 a barrel, about US$1.2bn a year on 1 mb/d (2024 rates).Solid bars are reported; dashed bars are Insight Stream estimates at the rates shown. Freight only: excludes tolls, demurrage and insurance.
Sources: Argus, 14 Jun 2024; S&P Global (Platts), 10 Sep 2026; Bloomberg via Energy Connects, 25 Sep 2026, citing Argus; S&P Global, 8 Sep 2026 (cargo size); McQuilling Partners, May 2024 (VLCC load). Dashed bars are Insight Stream estimates.

Two changes alter the arithmetic. Dredging at the Second Narrows, due in early 2027, lets Aframaxes leave full; on our estimate that cuts about US$1.6–1.7 a barrel from a direct voyage, about US$0.3 billion a year on 500 kb/d. Estimate When VLCC rates normalise, the California transfer still saves about US$1 a barrel even with full Aframaxes, so expect some cargoes to return to it; the direct route keeps the time advantage. Estimate Full loads also stretch the dock: at about 34 Aframax calls a month, Westridge can load about 625 kb/d at today’s cargo sizes and about 840 kb/d full. Estimate That headroom is what lets most of Trans Mountain’s optimization, to 1.19 mb/d, reach the water. Interpretation

The price ladder shows where the value goes. On 21 October, WCS traded US$28 below WTI at Hardisty and the Pacific grades at Westridge US$23–25 below Brent; in September, Canadian heavy for delivery to China sold above Brent. Reported The roughly US$27 gap between Westridge and China covers freight, time, risk and margin. Interpretation With the pipe full, that margin goes to whoever holds space on Trans Mountain and the ships, not to producers selling at Hardisty. Interpretation

Fig. 8From Hardisty to China: the price ladder
Prices against benchmarks, US$ per barrel, September–October 2026
What it shows → WCS traded US$28 below WTI at Hardisty and US$23–25 below Brent at Westridge in October. One Trans Mountain cargo sold delivered to China at US$3.70 above Brent.
How to read it → Each bar is a price against its benchmark: WTI for Hardisty, Brent for Westridge and China. Arrows mark the costs between steps.
Why it matters → With the pipe full, the value of Asian demand goes to whoever holds pipe space and ships, not to the barrel sold at Hardisty.
Price against each benchmark, US$ per barrel, autumn 2026+100-10-20-30−$28WCS at Hardisty, Albertavs WTI, 21 Oct (daily)−$24Pacific grades at Westridgevs Brent, 21 Oct: −23.15 to −24.55+$3.70Delivered to China (one cargo)vs Brent, Oct–Nov delivery+ Trans Mountain tollC$11–14 a barrel+ freight, voyage, riskand margin: ~US$27Benchmarks (WTI vs Brent) and dates differ, so the ladder is indicative, not a netback.
Sources: S&P Global, 21 Oct 2026 (WCS Hardisty, Pacific Cold Lake and Pacific Dilbit); Reuters via BOE Report, 10 Sep 2026 (delivered China cargo); CER (tolls). Indicative, not a netback.

What It Cost, and Who Is Paying

Ottawa bought the pipeline for C$4.5 billion in 2018, and the expansion cost C$34.2 billion, about six times the 2012 estimate. Reported In December 2024 it lent C$20 billion to Trans Mountain’s federal parent to repay an C$18 billion bank loan. Reported In 2025 the pipe earned C$3.0 billion of revenue, C$2.31 billion of adjusted EBITDA and C$556 million of net income, and paid its parent C$1.7 billion in dividends, interest and fees. Verified The company expects about C$11 billion of cash available for distribution over 2025–30. Reported Critics say the profit looks better than it is because most of the debt now sits with the parent, and that long-term contracts cover only about half the cost. Reported

Fig. 9The Crown’s ledger
What Canada put into Trans Mountain, and what the pipe now returns
What it shows → Canada paid C$4.5bn for the pipeline and C$34.2bn to expand it. In 2025 it earned C$3.0bn of revenue and paid its federal parent C$1.7bn.
How to read it → Left: what the Crown put in. Right: what the pipe returns, as reported by the company.
Why it matters → The pipe now earns cash, but on a cost base six times the original estimate. The same choices on tolls and contracts now face Pacific Link.
WHAT CANADA PUT INWHAT IT IS GETTING BACKC$4.5bnBought the pipeline, 2018from Kinder MorganC$34.2bnBuilt the expansionabout six times the 2012 estimateC$20bnFederal loan, Dec 2024to repay an C$18bn bank loanC$3.0bnRevenue, 2025EBITDA C$2.31bn; net income C$556mC$1.7bnPaid to its federal parent, 2025dividends, interest and fees~C$11bnCash for distribution, 2025–30company estimate; critics dispute the economicsCompany figures as reported; critics’ estimates differ. See sources below the chart.
Sources: Trans Mountain, Q4 and full-year 2025 results and fact sheet (Jul 2026); The Canadian Press, 11 May 2026; The Tyee, 23 Dec 2025, citing IEEFA and the Parliamentary Budget Officer.

Shippers pay for it through tolls. The heavy toll from Edmonton to Westridge rose from about C$4.30 a barrel before the expansion to C$10.84–13.18 for firm service and C$14.06 for spot. Verified The regulator approved a settlement on 28 September that lets Trans Mountain contract up to 90% of capacity, up from 80%, on 15- and 20-year terms, with new tolls from January 2027. Verified Locking in 90% means Trans Mountain fills first in any squeeze, and the Mainline absorbs the variation. Interpretation

Fig. 10Three times the old toll
Trans Mountain heavy crude tolls, Edmonton to Westridge, C$ per barrel, 2015–2026
What it shows → The heavy crude toll from Edmonton to Westridge rose from about C$4.30 a barrel before the expansion to C$10.84–13.18 firm and C$14.06 spot.
How to read it → Grey is the legacy toll; the blue band is the firm toll range across contract tiers; red is the spot toll. Quarterly ranges, in C$ per barrel.
Why it matters → Shippers pay about three times the old toll, and new tolls from January 2027 lock 90% of capacity into 15- and 20-year contracts.
Toll, Edmonton to Westridge, heavy crude, C$ per barrel (quarterly range)C$0C$4C$8C$12C$16201520172019202120232025Spot: C$14.06Firm: C$10.84–13.18Before: C$4.29–4.33New settlementtolls from Jan 2027;90% firm, 15–20 yrConverted at 6.2898 barrels per m³. The firm band spans the 15- and 20-year contract tiers.
Source: Canada Energy Regulator, Trans Mountain tolls (open data, to May 2026). Insight Stream conversion to C$ per barrel.

Ottawa has said it does not intend to own the pipe for good, but the company’s chief executive now calls it “a sovereign pipeline”. Reported And Ottawa is doubling down: Trans Mountain leads the development of Pacific Link, which the federal and Alberta governments would own equally, with at least 10% offered to Indigenous communities. Reported The Crown is becoming the long-term owner of Canada’s Pacific oil corridor. Interpretation


Our View to 2030, and Our Calls

Relief comes in steps: about 90 kb/d from a drag-reducing agent and full tanker loads in early 2027, 210 kb/d of mainline optimization by the end of 2028, and Prairie Connector’s 465 kb/d at the end of 2028 if it is sanctioned in mid-2027. Reported

Our view of the discount follows from that. Pipeline parity, the cost of moving heavy oil to the Gulf Coast plus its quality discount, is about US$13, which is also Alberta’s budget assumption. Reported When pipe space runs short, a congestion premium sits on top: about US$6 in May and June this year, before freight spiked, and up to US$20 in past squeezes. Estimate Assuming the war freight premium fades during 2027 and Venezuelan flows hold, we expect US$18–22 in 2027 and US$17–21 in 2028. With Prairie Connector, the discount returns to US$12–15 from 2029; without it, supply growth keeps it near US$20 until Pacific Link. Estimate The gap between US$13 and US$20 is worth about US$9 billion a year to Canadian producers. Estimate

Fig. 11Our view: the discount stays wide until new pipe arrives
WTI minus WCS, US$ per barrel: annual averages to 2026 and Insight Stream ranges for 2027–2030
What it shows → We expect the discount at US$18–22 in 2027 and US$17–21 in 2028. With Prairie Connector it returns to US$12–15 from 2029; without it, it stays near US$20.
How to read it → Navy bars are annual averages (2026 is January to September); the red bar is October's daily range. Shaded boxes are our ranges; the gold line is US$13, Alberta's budget assumption and pipeline parity.
Why it matters → The gap between US$13 and US$20 is worth about US$9bn a year to Canadian producers. Whether Prairie Connector is sanctioned in 2027 decides which path Alberta is on.
WTI minus WCS, US$ per barrel, annual average (2026 = January to September)$0$5$10$15$20$25$30201912.7202012.4202113.1202218.8202318.7202415.6202511.8202615.72027202820292030Oct daily18–2217–2112–1518–2312–1519–24US$13: Alberta budgetand pipeline parity (CAPP)Our view, 2027–282029–30 with Prairie Connector2029–30 without itInsight Stream view: pipeline parity of about US$13 plus a congestion premium while pipe space is short. Assumes the war freight premium fades during 2027.
Sources: Government of Alberta BVM and US EIA (history); CalRock via Reuters (October daily); CAPP, Understanding the WCS–WTI Differential (Apr 2026), for parity; Insight Stream view.

Pacific Link is the long answer, and its case rests on freight. The Alberta government estimates it at C$35.2–43.7 billion for 1 mb/d to a deep-water terminal at Roberts Bank; service is targeted for 2032–34. Reported IEEFA estimates its tolls at C$18.70–23.72 a barrel, about 60% above Trans Mountain’s committed tolls at the low cost, and argues shippers’ netbacks would be US$5–8 a barrel lower. Reported On our freight model, loading VLCCs at Roberts Bank would save about US$3.2 a barrel against a full Aframax at normal rates, about US$1.2 billion a year. Estimate That covers much of the toll gap at the low cost, not all of it; the rest has to come from a narrower discount, which is why the open season next spring is the number to watch. Interpretation

Table 3What could go wrong, and what to watch
RiskWhy it mattersWhat to watch
China concentrationAbout half of Westridge volumes go to China, and about a third to one refinerKorean, Japanese and Indian cargoes; any Chinese trade measure
The war premium fadesAsian buyers pay up for heavy oil that avoids Hormuz; that eases if Gulf flows returnChinese seaborne imports back near 10 mb/d; Pacific grade discounts
FreightRecord Aframax and VLCC rates take a large share of the Asian premium and close the Gulf Coast re-export routeVancouver–China Aframax and transpacific VLCC rates
VenezuelaMore Venezuelan heavy in the Gulf pushes Canadian barrels out; renewed sales to China would soften the Asian bidUS imports of Venezuelan crude (EIA); any cargo to China
US policyCrude is exempt from US tariffs so far; that can changeAny tariff, quota or licence on Canadian crude
DiluentEvery 1 mb/d of new pipe needs about 300 kb/d of diluent (Article 52)Condensate premium at Edmonton; Southern Lights expansion
Cost and tolls on Pacific LinkTolls well above Trans Mountain’s could leave it part-fullOpen season terms, spring 2027
Insight Stream interpretation.

What Trans Mountain teaches applies to every West Coast export, crude, LNG or LPG: Asia pays for supply that avoids chokepoints, but the dock decides the ship, the ship decides the freight, and contracts decide who fills first. Interpretation

Table 4Our calls
Our callByWhat would prove us wrong
The WCS discount averages US$18–22 in 2027, well above Alberta’s US$13 budget assumptionEnd-2027A 2027 average below US$18
Trans Mountain is apportioned again every winter until its mainline optimization is completeLate 2028A winter without apportionment before 2028
Asia keeps more than 65% of Westridge tankers even if Gulf flows recover2027Asia’s share below 60% for two quarters
Some Asian cargoes go back to the California VLCC transfer once VLCC rates normalise, even after dredging2027No transfers in 2027 despite normal VLCC rates
Prairie Connector is sanctioned in 2027, because the discount makes the case for itEnd-2027No investment decision by the end of 2027
Ottawa keeps Trans Mountain at least until Pacific Link is built2030A sale agreement before Pacific Link construction starts
Insight Stream interpretation. We will report back against these calls.

Trans Mountain did what it was built to do, and the world made it more valuable than its planners expected. The task now is the one it exposed: Canada’s oil, diluent and shipping capacity have to grow together, or the discount will keep taking back what the pivot earned.

IS

Insight Stream — LNG/LPG & Waterborne Trade Analysis

Condensate and diluent balances, LNG contract economics, LPG benchmarks and NGL export infrastructure. Independent market intelligence, built only on sources you can check.

Read More →