On 13 November Alberta cut the royalty on new oil sands projects to 2% of revenue for their first five years. Reported It did not touch the largest cost those projects will carry. In 2025 Alberta’s oil sands projects spent C$29.7 billion on diluent, the light oil they blend into bitumen so it can flow. That is more than twice the C$13.4 billion they paid in royalties. At the projects that blend it, diluent cost more than running the plants and building new ones combined. Verified

Part 1 of this series (Article 52) showed that every new export pipe raises how much diluent Alberta must bring in. This part puts dollars on it, using the province’s own project-by-project royalty data for 2016–2025: the size of the bill, what it really costs, who pays and how much falls on Albertans. It then prices Article 52’s paths to 2037, sets out what Alberta’s new Oil Sands Growth Program changes, and closes the series.

In 60 seconds

  • The bill. C$29.7bn in 2025, more than twice the royalties paid, and C$245bn over ten years.
  • The real cost is the spread. Diluent bought at about C$89 a barrel is sold back inside the blend at about C$75. That loss cost C$54bn in ten years.
  • Who pays. Eight operators buy 96% of it, led by Cenovus, Imperial, Suncor and Canadian Natural. The largest single buyer is a mine, Kearl.
  • Albertans’ share. Royalties absorb 24% of the penalty, up from 5% in 2016. Upgraded bitumen, which buys no diluent, loses royalties too, because its royalty price deducts diluent. Together the spread cost Albertans C$2.1bn in royalties in 2025, and each US$1 on it now moves them by C$0.22bn a year.
  • What comes next. New export pipes strengthen WCS but raise the volume blended. By 2037, with Pacific Link full, the penalty would be C$7.8–10.1bn a year with new import pipe and C$12.5–17.9bn without it, when rail would set the price of every barrel blended.
  • The new royalty program. Announced on 13 November, it charges new projects 2–6% of gross revenue for ten years. On those barrels Albertans carry 2–6 cents of each dollar of penalty, against about 34 cents at a project past payout today, and producers about three-quarters. It is built to fill Pacific Link, the path that needs the most diluent.
  • What to do. Every 100 kb/d of diluent avoided is worth C$0.5–0.7bn a year, and C$2.7bn when it frees full pipe. New import pipe is worth C$4.7–7.8bn a year by 2037. This article closes the series.

The idea in one barrel

Bitumen is too thick to flow in a pipeline, so producers mix in a light oil called diluent, about three barrels for every seven of bitumen. In 2025 a barrel of diluent cost about C$89. It travels to market inside the blend and is sold there as heavy oil, at about C$75. The producer gets most of its money back, but loses about C$13 on every barrel. Across 920,000 barrels a day, that loss was C$4.5 billion in 2025. We call it the diluent penalty. Because royalties are charged after diluent costs, about 24% of it, C$1.1 billion, came out of Alberta’s royalties.

Terms used in this article:

  • Diluent and condensate: diluent is any light oil blended into bitumen. Most of it is condensate, a light liquid produced with natural gas. The blend is called dilbit.
  • WCS and WTI: Western Canadian Select is the benchmark price for Canada’s heavy oil blend, quoted at Hardisty, Alberta. West Texas Intermediate is the US light oil benchmark. The gap between them is the WCS discount.
  • The spread: the price gap between condensate and WCS. It is what a producer loses on each barrel of diluent.
  • In-situ, mining and upgrading: in-situ projects heat bitumen underground with steam (SAGD is the main method) and must blend it to ship it. Some mines upgrade their bitumen into light synthetic crude and need almost no diluent.
  • Royalties and payout: royalties are Alberta’s share of oil sands revenue, paid to the Crown, meaning the province. Payout is the point at which a project has recovered its costs; its royalty rate jumps after that.
  • kb/d and mb/d: thousand and million barrels a day.

A C$30 Billion Line Item

Alberta publishes royalty data for every oil sands project: revenue, diluent cost, operating and capital costs, royalty rate and royalty paid. Added up, projects bought C$29.7 billion of diluent in 2025, against C$13.4 billion of royalties, C$25.2 billion of operating costs and C$11.9 billion of capital spending. Verified Over 2016–2025 they bought C$245 billion of diluent and paid C$81 billion in royalties. Verified

Fig. 1A bill larger than the royalties
Diluent bought, royalties paid and the diluent penalty, C$ billion, 2016–2025
What it shows → Oil sands projects bought C$29.7bn of diluent in 2025, against C$13.4bn of royalties. Over ten years: C$245bn of diluent, C$81bn of royalties and a C$54bn penalty.
How to read it → Navy bars are what projects paid for diluent; gold bars are royalties; red bars are the penalty: the part of the diluent cost that does not come back when the blend is sold.
Why it matters → The diluent bill is the largest cash flow in the oil sands after sales. The penalty is the part that is truly lost, and it moves with the condensate–WCS spread.
C$ billion a year, all oil sands royalty projects0102030402016 dil: C$12.6bn2016 roy: C$0.8bn2016 spread_cost: C$3.9bn20162017 dil: C$18.8bn2017 roy: C$2.5bn2017 spread_cost: C$4.6bn20172018 dil: C$24.2bn2018 roy: C$2.8bn2018 spread_cost: C$8.9bn20182019 dil: C$20.5bn2019 roy: C$4.9bn2019 spread_cost: C$3.3bn20192020 dil: C$14.5bn2020 roy: C$1.1bn2020 spread_cost: C$4.1bn20202021 dil: C$26.3bn2021 roy: C$7.8bn2021 spread_cost: C$5.1bn20212022 dil: C$35.8bn2022 roy: C$18.9bn2022 spread_cost: C$6.8bn20222023 dil: C$31.0bn2023 roy: C$12.6bn2023 spread_cost: C$7.1bn20232024 dil: C$31.6bn2024 roy: C$16.3bn2024 spread_cost: C$5.2bn20242025 dil: C$29.7bn2025 roy: C$13.4bn2025 spread_cost: C$4.5bn202529.713.44.58.9Diluent boughtRoyalties paidDiluent penalty (spread cost)Ten years: C$245bn of diluent, C$81bn of royalties, C$54bn of penaltySpread cost = (Edmonton condensate minus WCS) x diluent-equivalent volume. Royalty data for 2025 are as reported in May 2026.
Source: Government of Alberta, oil sands royalty project data, 2016–2025 (open data); penalty is an Insight Stream estimate from Bitumen Valuation Methodology prices.
Table 1The diluent bill, step by step
StepWhat it measures201620182025Ten years
1. Diluent blendedLight oil mixed into bitumen, thousand barrels a day625838920–
2. Price paidCondensate at Edmonton, C$ a barrel557989–
3. The bill (1 × 2)What projects spent on diluent, C$ billion12.624.229.7245
4. Price recoveredWhat the same barrel sells for inside the heavy oil blend (WCS at Hardisty), C$ a barrel385075–
5. Loss per barrel (2 − 4)The price gap, or spread, C$ a barrel172913–
6. The penalty (1 × 5)Money that does not come back, C$ billion3.98.94.554
7. Albertans’ sharePart of the penalty that comes out of royalties5%
C$0.2bn
11%
C$1.0bn
24%
C$1.1bn
C$9.1bn
8. Plus upgraded bitumenRoyalty lost on bitumen valued under the BVM formula, C$ billion0.10.61.07.8
For comparisonRoyalties the oil sands paid, C$ billion0.82.813.481
Sources: Government of Alberta, oil sands royalty project data, 2016–2025 (as of May 2026), and its published condensate and WCS prices. Rows 1 and 5–8 are Insight Stream estimates; method below. Row 1 is the diluent bill divided by the condensate price.

The bill tracks price and volume. It was C$12.6 billion in 2016, when oil was cheap, C$35.8 billion in 2022, when it was dear, and has held near C$30 billion since. Verified Behind it, the volume blended rose from about 625 kb/d to 920 kb/d as in-situ output grew. Estimate That is more than the 781 kb/d of condensate the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER) counts, because projects also blend synthetic crude and other light oils. Interpretation Table 1 walks through the arithmetic.

These figures cover Alberta’s oil sands royalty projects only; Saskatchewan heavy oil and Alberta’s conventional heavy oil blend diluent too, so the national bill is larger. Interpretation


Diluent Is the Largest Cost at the Projects That Use It

At the 83 projects whose diluent cost exceeds 5% of revenue, which produced about 2,219 kb/d of bitumen in 2025, diluent took C$37 of every C$100 of blend revenue. Estimate Operating costs took C$17, capital C$10 and royalties C$11. Estimate Per barrel of bitumen, that is C$37 of diluent against C$10 of royalties. Estimate In 2018, with heavy oil deeply discounted, diluent took C$54 of every C$100 and royalties less than C$4. Estimate

Fig. 2Where C$100 of blend revenue goes
Projects that blend diluent, share of blend revenue, 2018 and 2025
What it shows → At projects that blend diluent, it took C$37 of every C$100 of blend revenue in 2025, more than operating and capital costs combined. In 2018 it took C$54.
How to read it → Each bar splits C$100 of blend revenue at projects whose diluent cost is more than 5% of revenue. 'Everything else' covers other costs, taxes and margin.
Why it matters → Diluent is mostly recovered when the blend is sold, but it sets how much revenue a project needs before it earns anything.
Share of blend revenue, projects whose diluent cost exceeds 5% of revenue201854Diluent23Operating12Capital7Everything else202537Diluent11Royalties17Operating10Capital26Everything else2025, per barrel of bitumen: blend revenue C$99, diluent C$37, royalties C$10, operating C$16, capital C$10Everything else = other allowed costs, corporate costs, taxes and margin. Diluent is largely recovered when the blend is sold.
Source: Government of Alberta, oil sands royalty project data. Insight Stream grouping and calculation.

This is not only a story about steam projects. Two mines ship diluted bitumen too: Kearl bought C$3.7 billion of diluent in 2025, more than any other project, and Fort Hills C$1.5 billion. Verified Mines with upgraders, which turn bitumen into synthetic crude, buy almost none. Verified Syncrude, Suncor’s base plant, Horizon, Muskeg River and Jackpine produced about 1,260 kb/d of bitumen in 2025 without buying diluent. Verified As Section V shows, they still feel the spread through their royalties. Interpretation


The Round Trip: Bought as Light Oil, Sold as Heavy

Most of the C$29.7 billion comes back. Diluent travels to market inside the blend and is paid for again when the blend is sold. What doesn’t come back is the difference in price: diluent is bought at the condensate price and sold back at the heavy oil price. Interpretation In 2025 Edmonton condensate averaged about C$88.55 a barrel and WCS at Hardisty about C$75.07, so every barrel of diluent lost about C$13.48. Verified On about 920 kb/d, that is a penalty of C$4.5 billion. Estimate Article 52 put it at C$3.8 billion using the AER’s smaller condensate-only volume; the difference is the other light oils projects report as diluent. Estimate

Fig. 3The diluent round trip
How diluent enters, travels and leaves the oil sands, with 2025 prices
What it shows → Diluent is bought at about C$89 a barrel and sold back inside the blend at about C$75. The C$13.48 gap is lost on every barrel of diluent.
How to read it → Boxes follow the barrel: condensate from Alberta gas plants and from the US and BC, blended at the oil sands, sold as Western Canadian Select, then recovered by refiners. The red panel shows the cost.
Why it matters → The real cost of diluent is the spread, not the purchase. Anything that widens it, a cheaper WCS or dearer condensate, raises the penalty.
Alberta gas plants~425 kb/d of condensateMontney and DuvernayBrought in: US and BC~357 kb/dtwo pipelines from Chicago, BC, railOil sands blendingbuy diluent at ~C$88.55/bbl~30% of every barrel shippedSold as WCS~C$75.07/bbl (2025)diluent sold at the heavy priceRefiners recover itUS Midwest, Gulf Coast, Asialight ends back into the marketsome comes back to Alberta as imported diluentTHE PENALTYDiluent bought at C$88.55 is sold back at C$75.07: about C$13.48 lost on every barrel of diluent in 2025.On ~920 kb/d of diluent-equivalent volume, that is about C$4.5 billion a year; C$8.9 billion in 2018.Volumes: AER ST98-2026 (pentanes plus, 2025). Prices: Government of Alberta BVM components, 2025 averages, converted at the average exchange rate.
Sources: AER ST98-2026 (pentanes plus volumes, 2025); Government of Alberta, BVM components (prices); Insight Stream estimates.

Over ten years the penalty came to C$54 billion, two-thirds of everything the oil sands paid in royalties. Estimate It swings with the spread. In 2018, when pipes were full and WCS collapsed, the spread averaged US$22.55 and the penalty hit C$8.9 billion. Estimate In 2025 it averaged US$9.65. Verified A 2018 spread at today’s volumes would cost about C$10.6 billion a year. Albertans’ share of it would be about C$2.5 billion, more than twice 2018’s C$1.0 billion, because more of the diluent is now bought by projects on the higher royalty rate. Estimate

Fig. 4The spread that sets the penalty
Edmonton condensate minus WCS at Hardisty, US$ per barrel, monthly, 2015–September 2026
What it shows → The condensate–WCS spread averaged US$9.65 in 2025 and US$13.68 in January–September 2026, with a peak of US$23.46 in May. It averaged US$22.55 in 2018.
How to read it → The line is the monthly gap between the price of condensate at Edmonton and the price of heavy oil (WCS) at Hardisty, in US$ a barrel. Coloured bars mark annual averages.
Why it matters → Every US$1 on the spread costs producers about C$0.47bn a year at today's volumes. The spread widens when heavy oil is cheap and light oil is scarce, as in 2026.
Edmonton condensate minus WCS at Hardisty, US$ per barrel, monthly average$0$5$10$15$20$25$30$352015201620172018201920202021202220232024202520262018 average $22.552025 average $9.65May 2026: $23.462026 Jan–Sep $13.68Source: Government of Alberta, Bitumen Valuation Methodology components (condensate and WCS), to September 2026.
Source: Government of Alberta, Bitumen Valuation Methodology components.

2026 shows how fast it moves. The spread averaged US$13.68 in January–September, 42% above 2025, and reached US$23.46 in May. Verified In April, condensate at Fort Saskatchewan traded about US$10.80 above WTI as the Gulf war tightened light crude. Reported The spread is, in effect, the WCS discount minus Edmonton condensate’s own small discount to WTI, US$2.11 in 2025: condensate in Edmonton trades close to WTI almost all the time, so it widens from both sides: when pipes and freight are tight, and when light oil is short (Article 53). Interpretation


Eight Companies Buy 96% of the Diluent

Cenovus bought C$8.6 billion of diluent in 2025, Imperial C$5.5 billion, Suncor C$5.4 billion including Fort Hills, and Canadian Natural C$4.0 billion. Verified Diluent was 41% of blend revenue at ConocoPhillips and 43% at CNOOC, whose Alberta output is all in-situ, against 14% at Canadian Natural, which upgrades much of its bitumen. Verified On our estimate, the penalty cost Cenovus about C$1.3 billion in 2025. Estimate The five largest buyers by project were Kearl (C$3.7 billion), Christina Lake (C$3.5 billion), Firebag (C$3.2 billion), Foster Creek (C$2.8 billion) and Cold Lake (C$1.8 billion). Verified

Fig. 5Who buys the diluent
Diluent bought in 2025 by operator, with intensity and estimated penalty
What it shows → Eight operators bought 96% of reported diluent in 2025, led by Cenovus (C$8.6bn), Imperial (C$5.5bn) and Suncor (C$5.4bn).
How to read it → Bars are diluent bought in 2025. The columns give diluent per barrel of bitumen at projects that blend, diluent as a share of blend revenue, and each operator's estimated penalty.
Why it matters → Producers that upgrade or refine their heavy oil recover part of the penalty downstream. Pure in-situ producers carry all of it.
Diluent cost in 2025, C$ billion, by operator (all royalty projects)C$ per bbl of bitumen% of blend revenuepenalty, C$bnCenovus8.64039%1.31Imperial5.53635%0.84Suncor5.43325%0.82Canadian Natural4.03014%0.61ConocoPhillips2.44341%0.36CNOOC1.34643%0.19Strathcona0.94038%0.13Athabasca0.54042%0.08These eight operators bought 96% of reported diluent. Per-barrel figures cover projects whose diluent exceeds 5% of revenue; Suncor includes Fort Hills.
Source: Government of Alberta, oil sands royalty project data, 2025. Penalty is an Insight Stream estimate at the 2025 spread.

Exposure is not the same as cost. Producers that upgrade, or own refineries that run heavy crude, earn back part of a wide spread downstream, and an integrated miner gains twice: its synthetic crude sells at a light-oil price while its royalty base falls with the spread (Section V). Some also produce condensate upstream and earn on one side of the spread what they lose on the other, though rarely in the same volume: Cenovus said on its second-quarter call that it uses about 240,000 b/d and produces about 20,000 b/d outside its upgrader. Reported Canadian Natural, with its own gas and liquids production, offsets more of it. Interpretation Pure in-situ producers with no upstream liquids carry all of it. Interpretation


From 5% to a Quarter of the Penalty

Royalties are charged on the bitumen, not on the blend. Alberta takes what a project earns from selling the blend and subtracts the cost of the diluent in it. Until the project has recovered its costs, the royalty is 1–9% of that revenue. After payout, it is the greater of that or 25–40% of revenue less costs, with both rates rising with the oil price. Verified So every dollar of diluent penalty lowers royalties by the project’s rate: a few cents before payout, 25 to 40 cents after it. Interpretation

Fig. 6Royalties Albertans lose to the spread
Royalties lost to the condensate–WCS spread through diluent buyers and through upgraded bitumen, C$ billion, 2016–2025
What it shows → Albertans lost about C$2.1bn of royalties to the spread in 2025: C$1.1bn through projects that buy diluent and C$1.0bn through upgraded bitumen, which buys none. Over ten years, C$17bn.
How to read it → Gold: the royalty share of the penalty at projects that buy diluent. Teal: royalties lost on upgraded bitumen, whose royalty price is set by a formula that deducts diluent. Red labels: Albertans’ share of the penalty itself.
Why it matters → Every barrel of bitumen carries the spread into the royalty base, whether or not diluent is ever bought for it. Albertans’ exposure is about twice what the diluent buyers alone suggest.
Royalties lost to the condensate–WCS spread, C$ billion a year01230.320165%0.820178%1.6201811%0.8201913%0.8202010%1.5202117%3.3202225%3.3202324%2.4202425%2.1202524%Projects that buy diluentUpgraded bitumen under the BVMRed: Albertans’ share of the penaltyTen years: C$9.1bn through diluent buyers and C$7.8bn through upgraded bitumen. Insight Stream estimates; BVM at 0.5 barrels of diluent per barrel.
Source: Insight Stream estimate from Government of Alberta royalty project data, BVM components and the BVM implementation model.

As the large SAGD projects have passed payout, the share of diluent bought by projects past payout rose from 32% in 2016 to 66% in 2025. Verified Eighteen projects passed payout between 2016 and 2025, among them Christina Lake in 2019, Firebag in 2022 and Christina Lake Regional in 2024; together they bought C$11.3 billion of diluent in 2025. Verified The Crown’s share of the penalty rose from 5% to 24%, or C$1.07 billion in 2025 and C$9.1 billion over the decade. Estimate Each US$1 a barrel on the spread now costs producers about C$0.47 billion a year and the Crown about C$0.11 billion. Estimate

At 2025 prices a C$1 penalty cut a post-payout project’s royalty by about 33.5 cents, and that of a project still recovering its costs, such as Kearl or Fort Hills, by about 5.6 cents. Verified Once Kearl reaches payout, Albertans’ share of the whole penalty rises by about 3.5 points, to about 27%. Estimate

Upgraded bitumen counts too

The royalty data show only the diluent projects buy, and that misses a second channel. Interpretation Alberta levies royalty on clean bitumen at the project boundary, valued at the first sale to an unrelated buyer. Verified Syncrude and Suncor’s base plant were built with mines and upgraders together, before there was a market for diluted bitumen, and cannot sell unprocessed bitumen; like every upgrader, they elected to keep the upgrader outside the royalty project, so its costs and margins sit outside the royalty calculation. Reported For bitumen with no arm’s-length sale, Alberta sets the royalty price with its Bitumen Valuation Methodology (BVM): a barrel of WCS, less the condensate it would take to make it, about half a barrel per barrel of bitumen. Verified The five upgrader mines reported about C$66 a barrel in 2025, close to what the formula gives. Estimate

So when condensate rises against WCS, the royalty price of upgraded bitumen falls, though not a barrel of diluent was bought. Interpretation On those mines’ 1,260 kb/d, at a 33.5% royalty rate, that cost Albertans about C$1.0 billion in 2025 and C$7.8 billion over ten years. Estimate With the diluent buyers, the spread cost about C$2.1 billion in royalties last year, and each US$1 on it now moves royalties by about C$0.22 billion, twice what the buyers alone suggest. Estimate The integrated producers keep that saving, while their synthetic crude sells at a light-oil price. Interpretation

Alberta’s budget shows that each US$1 on WTI is worth about C$680 million a year. Reported It shows no sensitivity to condensate, yet each US$1 on the condensate–WCS spread moves royalties by about C$0.22 billion, a third as much as a dollar on oil. Estimate At 2026’s spread, the royalties lost on both channels, about C$3.0 billion, are more than a tenth of the roughly C$23 billion the province now expects from all resource royalties. Estimate

Corporate income tax adds a second public share. Producers deduct diluent before tax at a combined rate of 23%, so for a taxpaying producer Alberta carries about 30% of the penalty and Ottawa about 11%, C$1.35 billion and C$0.5 billion in 2025. Estimate The penalty is a shared public cost, not only a corporate one. Interpretation


Export Pipe Strengthens Heavy Oil. Only Import Pipe Holds Down Condensate.

On Article 52’s paths ahead, the volume blended rises from 920 kb/d today to about 1,131 kb/d in 2029, as the pipes planned before Pacific Link fill, and 1,526 kb/d by 2037 with Pacific Link full. At 2025 prices the bill rises from C$29.7 billion to C$49 billion a year. Estimate

The spread has two sides, and new pipes move them in opposite directions. On the heavy-oil side, new export pipe narrows the WCS discount. Article 53 expects it to fall from US$18–22 in 2027 to US$12–15 once Prairie Connector opens, close to pipeline parity of about US$13, the cost of moving heavy oil to the Gulf Coast plus its quality discount. Estimate With condensate about US$2 below WTI, as in 2025, that would put the spread near US$10–13, below this year’s US$13.68. Estimate On the condensate side, Alberta is short, so Edmonton condensate trades close to what it costs to bring a US barrel north by pipe. Interpretation Once import pipes are full, the extra barrels must come by rail, which costs roughly twice a pipeline toll: CAPP has put rail from Alberta to the US Gulf Coast at US$15–22 a barrel against a pipeline toll of about US$9, and diluent moving the other way faces similar costs (Article 52). Reported Condensate would then have to rise by about the difference, US$6–13 a barrel, to pull those barrels in, and that premium is paid on every barrel blended, Alberta’s own included, because a buyer pays the market price whoever the seller is. Estimate

Fig. 7The penalty at each milestone, and who carries it
Diluent penalty, C$ billion a year, split by who carries it, 2025 to 2037
What it shows → The penalty was C$4.5bn in 2025. As new export pipe strengthens WCS, it would be about C$7.8–10.1bn a year by 2037 with Pacific Link full, if import pipe is also built. Without new import pipe, rail sets the price of condensate and it becomes C$12.5–17.9bn.
How to read it → Each bar is one milestone on Article 52’s paths. Colours split who carries the loss: producers after tax, Albertans through royalties, Alberta and Ottawa through corporate tax. Solid bars are the low end of each range; dashed boxes the high end.
Why it matters → New export pipe fixes the heavy-oil side of the spread. Only new import pipe fixes the condensate side. Without it, the 2037 penalty is 60–80% higher.
Diluent penalty, C$ billion a year, split by who carries it051015204.52025actual6.42026at this year'sspread5.8–7.52029new pipes open,WCS stronger6.3–8.12037no Pacific Link7.8–10.12037Pacific Link andimport pipe12.5–17.92037Pacific Link, noimport pipeProducers, after taxAlbertans, through royaltiesAlberta corporate taxOttawa corporate taxSolid: low end of range; dashed: high end. 2029–37 at a US$10–13 spread as new export pipe strengthens WCS; with no import pipe, rail adds US$6–13. Pacific Link cases: its new barrels pay the new 2–6% program rate.
Insight Stream estimates. Volumes follow Article 52’s year-by-year forecast; royalty share of 24% (2025 actual), and about 20% in the Pacific Link cases, where new barrels pay the new program’s 2–6%; corporate tax at 15% federal and 8% Alberta, for producers paying tax.

Put together, the penalty rises on every path, because volume grows even as WCS strengthens. At a spread of US$10–13 it would be C$5.8–7.5 billion a year in 2029, C$6.3–8.1 billion by 2037 without Pacific Link, and C$7.8–10.1 billion with it, if import pipe keeps pace. Estimate Without new import pipe the 2037 figure becomes C$12.5–17.9 billion. Estimate With Pacific Link’s new barrels on the new program’s 2–6% rate (below), Albertans would then lose about C$2.5–3.6 billion a year in royalties on the penalty, plus C$1.7–2.5 billion on upgraded bitumen, and Ottawa about C$1.5–2.2 billion in tax, before the higher royalty rates Kearl, Fort Hills and Surmont pay once they reach payout. Estimate In other words, Pacific Link fixes the heavy-oil half of the problem and makes the condensate half bigger. Interpretation

What Alberta’s new royalty program changes

On 13 November Alberta announced the Oil Sands Growth Program. Approved projects pay 2% of gross revenue for their first five years, rising by one point a year to 6% in years nine and ten, and then return to the regular framework. Reported It is open to new or expanded projects of at least 5,000 b/d that sit outside the boundary of an approved project, with applications from spring 2027. Reported The aim is to fill new export pipe, Pacific Link included, and to double Alberta’s oil output to 8 million barrels a day. Reported

It changes none of the history in this article: it covers new projects only, and few will produce before the end of the decade. Interpretation What it changes is who carries the penalty on new barrels. A project past payout today gives up about 34 cents of royalty for every dollar of penalty; a program project gives up 2 to 6 cents for its first ten years (Fig. 8). Estimate Its owner carries about 74 cents after tax, against about 51 cents past payout. Estimate On the roughly 298 kb/d of extra diluent that Pacific Link’s barrels would need, Albertans’ share of the 2037 penalty falls from 24% to about 20%, and the royalties lost in the no-import-pipe case from C$3.0–4.2 billion to C$2.5–3.6 billion a year. Estimate The penalty itself does not shrink: the diluent still has to be bought at the light price and sold back at the heavy one. Interpretation

Fig. 8The new program moves the penalty back to producers
Who carries each C$1 of diluent penalty, by royalty position
What it shows → A project past payout gives up about 34 cents of royalty for every C$1 of diluent penalty. A project in the new program gives up 2–6 cents for ten years, so its owner carries about 74 cents after tax.
How to read it → Each bar is C$1 of penalty, split by who carries it: the producer after tax, Albertans through royalties, and Alberta and Ottawa through corporate tax. Numbers are cents.
Why it matters → The program does not shrink the diluent penalty. It moves it from the public purse to the producer, which makes the diluent plan a commercial decision as much as a policy one.
Each C$1 of diluent penalty, split by who carries it (cents)5134510Past payout, todayregular framework, 2025 average rate5924611Oil sands average, 2025all projects that buy diluent736814Before payout, todayregular framework, 2025 rate726814New program, years 9–106% of gross revenue752815New program, years 1–52% of gross revenueProducers, after taxAlbertans, through royaltiesAlberta corporate taxOttawa corporate taxCents of each C$1 of penalty. Royalty share equals the royalty rate on bitumen value; tax applies to producers paying corporate tax.
Insight Stream estimates. Royalty rates from Government of Alberta royalty data (2025) and the Oil Sands Growth Program (13 November 2026); corporate tax at 15% federal and 8% Alberta.

The larger effect is on volume. The program is built to deliver the barrels behind this article’s highest-diluent path, Pacific Link full by 2037, and makes that path more likely. Interpretation Each extra 1 mb/d of bitumen shipped as dilbit needs about 429 kb/d of diluent: a bill of about C$14 billion a year at 2025 prices, and a penalty of C$2.2–2.8 billion a year at a US$10–13 spread, or C$3.5–5.0 billion if rail sets the price. Estimate An 8 mb/d province would need several such steps. Interpretation

The province also expects oil sands growth to lift demand for the condensate Alberta’s gas plants produce. Reported It will: Section VII shows that market is already worth C$13.7 billion a year to Alberta producers. Estimate But the program does not lower the cost of that condensate. Montney and Duvernay supply grows when condensate is dear, so the signal that draws it out is the spread itself. Interpretation From January 2027, gas, NGLs and field condensate all pay royalty under the Modernized Royalty Framework, at rates well below those on bitumen past payout. Reported

In short, the program lowers the cost of building new oil sands and leaves the cost of blending them where it was. It makes a diluent plan more urgent, and makes it more the producers’ problem than the province’s. Because the program is application-based, Alberta also gains a simple lever: ask each applicant where its diluent will come from. Interpretation

Who receives the money matters as much as who pays it. Each US$1 condensate rises against WCS costs oil sands projects about C$0.47 billion a year. About C$0.22 billion goes to Alberta’s own condensate producers and about C$0.18 billion to suppliers in the US and BC. Estimate Royalties fall by C$0.11 billion on diluted bitumen and by about C$0.11 billion on upgraded bitumen, a saving the integrated producers keep. Estimate A diluent shortage moves money from the oil sands to the Montney and south of the border more than it destroys it. Interpretation It is still a net loss to Alberta’s treasury: condensate pays royalty at much lower rates than bitumen after payout, and the royalties on BC condensate go to BC. Reported

Fig. 9Who pays, and who receives, when condensate rises
Each US$1 a barrel rise in condensate against WCS, C$ billion a year at 2025 volumes
What it shows → Each US$1 a barrel that condensate rises against WCS costs oil sands projects about C$0.47bn a year. About C$0.22bn of it goes to Alberta’s own condensate producers and C$0.18bn to suppliers in the US and BC.
How to read it → The top bar splits who pays; the bottom bar splits who receives the same money. Both are C$ billion a year for a US$1 move, at 2025 volumes.
Why it matters → A diluent shortage is a transfer as much as a cost. Albertans lose through bitumen royalties, and win back only a little through condensate royalties, which are charged at much lower rates.
Each US$1 a barrel that condensate rises against WCS moves about C$0.47 billion a year, at 2025 volumesWho pays0.28Producers, after tax0.11Albertans: lower royalties0.030.05Who receives0.22Alberta condensate producers0.18Suppliers in the US and BC0.07Other light oilsAlberta tax 0.03 · Ottawa tax 0.05Not shown: royalties on upgraded bitumen also fall, by about C$0.11bn, which integrated producers keep.Insight Stream estimates. Receipts use AER 2025 volumes (425 kb/d made in Alberta, 357 kb/d brought in). Tax split assumes producers pay 23% corporate tax.
Insight Stream estimates from Government of Alberta royalty data and AER ST98-2026 volumes.

The worst case is not a high price but no barrel at all. Article 52 found that every 100 kb/d of diluent Alberta cannot bring in strands about C$6 billion a year of bitumen, many times the cost of the dearest rail. Estimate

The slower path is not free either. If oil sands growth stays near the regulator’s forecast, diluent needs grow slowly and the penalty rises only to about C$5.7–7.4 billion a year, but the new contracted pipes would pull barrels off Enbridge’s Mainline, which has no long-term contracts. Under the settlement that runs to the end of 2028, each 50 kb/d lost raises its toll by US$0.035 a barrel for the shippers that remain (Article 52). Verified Either the oil sands grow and pay more for diluent, or they don’t and pay more for pipe. Interpretation Only once Pacific Link flows could a Mainline line be spared and reversed to bring diluent in, which would fix both. Interpretation


A Market for the Montney, the US Gulf and Midwest

On the AER’s volumes, about C$13.7 billion of 2025 diluent spending went to Alberta’s condensate producers, about as much as the oil sands paid in royalties, and about C$11.5 billion to supply from the US and BC. Estimate The US exported 176 kb/d of natural gasoline in 2025, nearly all of it to Canada. Verified Diluent demand is part of what keeps liquids-rich Montney and Duvernay wells drilling (Articles 50 and 52). Interpretation

The penalty itself is split between the pipelines that carry diluent to market, since WCS at Hardisty is priced after the tolls, and the refiners that buy diluted bitumen. A refiner pays the heavy price for the diluent in the blend and recovers it as light product, so part of the C$4.5 billion is a transfer to plants in the US Midwest, the Gulf Coast and Asia. Interpretation

Fig. 10Who receives the diluent dollars
2025 diluent spending by source, C$ billion
What it shows → Of the C$29.7bn spent on diluent in 2025, about C$13.7bn went to Alberta condensate producers and C$11.5bn to supply brought in from the US and BC.
How to read it → The bar splits 2025 diluent spending by source. Volumes are from the AER, valued at the 2025 Edmonton condensate price; the remainder is other blending stocks and costs.
Why it matters → The diluent bill is also an export market for US gas plants and a revenue stream for the Montney, which ties Alberta's oil to the gas and LNG build-out.
Who received the C$29.7 billion of diluent spending in 2025, C$ billion (Insight Stream estimate)C$13.7bnAlberta condensate producers~425 kb/dC$11.5bnBrought in from the US and BC~357 kb/dC$4.5bnOther blending stocks and costssynthetic crude, naphtha, transportThe US exported 176 kb/d of natural gasoline in 2025, nearly all of it to Canada (EIA).Volumes from AER ST98-2026, valued at the 2025 Edmonton condensate price; "other" is the remainder of reported diluent cost.
Sources: AER ST98-2026; US EIA, Today in Energy (2026); Insight Stream estimates at the 2025 condensate price.

Two things tighten the market. Venezuela, allowed to import US diluent since February, now competes with Alberta for it. Reported And diluent shipped to Asia in Trans Mountain’s dilbit never returns: about 150 kb/d if late-2025 Westridge loadings carried a typical 30%, and about 300 kb/d more with Pacific Link. Estimate Every barrel that leaves by sea must be replaced. Interpretation


The Value of Every Barrel of Diluent Avoided

Every 100 kb/d of diluent the industry can avoid is worth about C$0.5 billion a year of penalty at the 2025 spread, C$0.7 billion at 2026’s and C$1.2 billion at May 2026’s. Estimate When pipes are full, it is worth more: it frees 100 kb/d of pipe for more heavy oil, about C$2.7 billion a year of sales at the 2025 WCS price. Estimate Article 52 set out the options: more import pipe, diluent recovery for rail, partial upgrading and condensate splitters. The cheapest of all is planning: Pacific Link alone would need about 300 kb/d of diluent, and counting it before the pipe is approved costs nothing. Interpretation

What would shrink the penalty faster than we expect? A narrower WCS discount as freight normalizes; LNG condensate arriving early; import pipe before 2029; or diluent-saving technology at scale. Each would show first in the monthly spread in Fig. 4. Interpretation

What each fix is worth
C$0.5–0.7bn
a year for every 100 kb/d of diluent avoided
Use less diluent

Partial upgrading, solvent-assisted recovery and diluent recovery units cut the barrels blended. The range is the 2025 and 2026 spreads.

C$2.7bn
a year of extra sales for every 100 kb/d freed
Free the pipe

When export pipes are full, each barrel of diluent removed makes room for a barrel of heavy oil, at the 2025 WCS price.

C$4.7–7.8bn
a year by 2037 that new import pipe saves, with Pacific Link full
Bring diluent in by pipe

If rail sets the price, every barrel blended pays the premium, Alberta’s own included. Import pipe before the squeeze keeps the price at pipeline cost.

C$0.47bn
a year at stake for every US$1 on the spread
Hedge the spread

Condensate–WCS swaps and term supply contracts turn a moving exposure into a known cost.

What it means for each decision-maker
~30%
of the penalty, about C$1.35bn in 2025
Government of Alberta

Lower royalties plus provincial corporate tax, rising as big projects reach payout. Upgraded bitumen adds about C$1.0bn more in royalties.

The move: publish a condensate sensitivity in the budget, and count diluent in Pacific Link planning, and ask each Oil Sands Growth Program applicant where its diluent will come from.
~11%
of the penalty, about C$0.5bn in 2025
Federal government and Major Projects Office

Through corporate tax. Every export pipe Ottawa backs adds diluent demand of about 30% of its capacity.

The move: make a diluent supply or return plan a condition of pipeline open seasons.
C$0.47bn
a year for every US$1 on the spread, across the industry
In-situ producers

Diluent is 35–43% of blend revenue at the producers with no upgrader, and its price is set at Edmonton. On new program barrels they carry about three-quarters of the penalty.

The move: hedge the spread, sign term supply and test lower-diluent technology.
C$13.7bn
of Alberta condensate sold into diluent in 2025
Montney and Duvernay producers

A shortage pays them: about C$0.22bn a year more for every US$1 condensate rises.

The move: condensate-rich drilling stays the most valuable drilling in the basin while the pipes fill.
2029
the year import capacity runs out (Article 52)
Midstream, rail and Indigenous partners

First Nation and Métis owners already hold part of the Norlite diluent line, and Pacific Link offers at least 10%.

The move: offer import pipe, return capacity or diluent recovery for rail before the squeeze.
C$11.5bn
a year of diluent sold into Alberta
US and BC suppliers

Canada is almost the only buyer of US natural gasoline, and refiners buy the diluent back at the heavy price.

The move: long-term supply deals; both sides have reason to keep this flow out of trade disputes.
Our calls
1
The spread between condensate and WCS averages more than US$15 in 2027, about 50% above 2025, as heavy discounts stay wide and diluent tightens
We are wrong if: A 2027 average below US$12.
End-2027
2
Albertans’ share of the diluent penalty stays above 20% in every year to 2030
We are wrong if: Any year below 20% in the royalty data.
2030
3
The volume blended in Alberta’s royalty data passes 1 mb/d by 2028
We are wrong if: A 2028 volume below 1 mb/d.
2028 data
4
Alberta’s diluent bill passes C$35bn a year by 2030, without any rise in condensate prices
We are wrong if: A 2030 bill below C$35bn.
2030 data
Insight Stream interpretation. Article 52’s six calls on routes and timing still stand. We will report back against all ten when the regulator’s next outlook and the 2026 royalty data are published in mid-2027.

This closes the series. Part 1 showed how much diluent Alberta will need and where it can come from. Part 2 shows what it costs: a C$30 billion bill, a penalty of C$4.5 billion a year that could more than double, and more than 40% of it carried by Albertans and Canadians through royalties and tax. The pipes Canada is planning will raise all three. Alberta’s new royalty program lowers the cost of building new oil sands, not the cost of blending them, and on new barrels it leaves the penalty mostly with producers. Counting the diluent in every pipeline plan and every budget is the cheapest decision left. We will report back against our ten calls in mid-2027.

IS

Insight Stream — LNG/LPG & Waterborne Trade Analysis

Condensate and diluent balances, LNG contract economics, LPG benchmarks and NGL export infrastructure. Independent market intelligence, built only on sources you can check.

Read More →