On 16 October the United States held 105.8 million barrels of propane, the most for the time of year in EIA records going back to 1993 and 13% above the five-year average. NOAA expects a strong to very strong El Niño through March, the pattern that usually brings a mild winter to Canada and the northern United States. The last time record stocks met a very strong El Niño, in 2015–16, Mont Belvieu propane fell to 33¢ a gallon. In the week to 20 October it averaged 110¢.
Article 47 explained why Alberta propane trades at a fifth of the crude price. This piece asks the winter question for the whole continent: is there enough propane, and is it where people burn it? Our answer: plenty in total, too little where it is needed. The war has turned the US Gulf Coast into the world’s spare propane tank, beside export docks that have added up to 360,000 b/d of propane capacity since May and will add about 300,000 b/d more by the end of the year. Western Canada is long too, waiting for a new West Coast export terminal in March. Every gallon a household in Ohio, New York or Ontario burns this winter has to be bid away from a ship bound for Asia.
In 60 seconds
- Record barrels, half the cover. US stocks are 105.8 MMbbl, a record, but exports have more than tripled since 2015. They cover 35 days of demand plus exports, against 65 in 2015.
- The war made the Gulf Coast the world’s spare tank. The Hormuz closure removed 7 Mt+ of Middle East LPG, and the US share of China’s imports rose from 20% to 57%. Why it matters: stocks held as insurance keep prices high even with tanks full.
- The surplus is in the wrong place. Gulf Coast stocks are 24% above normal; the Midwest and East Coast are below. Mont Belvieu now trades at the Japanese price less freight and the dock.
- The new docks decide the winter. On our model, a normal winter with the new Houston capacity ends March at 36 MMbbl, near the lowest since 2015. A cold one only balances if the price rises enough to slow exports.
- Western Canada: long now, shorter from March. Stocks are 26% above last year and Alberta propane fetched 42¢ in August. A delayed 56 kb/d West Coast terminal opens in March 2027; with a 30 kb/d expansion, overseas capacity could rise 80%.
- Eastern Canada: lean and tied to the US. Ontario entered last winter 31% below normal and depends on Line 5, rail and US imports, the routes that strain first in a cold snap.
- Distributors are absorbing the rise. US wholesale propane is up 57% on a year ago, residential only 11%.
| Market | What sets the price this winter | Mid-October |
|---|---|---|
| Mont Belvieu (US Gulf) | The Asian price, less freight and the dock | 110¢/gal |
| US Midwest | Mont Belvieu plus the cost of moving barrels north; local stocks in a cold snap | 122¢ wholesale |
| US East Coast | Gulf supply by pipeline, rail and ship; regional stocks | 132¢ wholesale |
| Delivered North Asia | Middle East supply still disrupted; US and Canadian cargoes fill the gap | 185¢ (9 Oct) |
| Alberta | The export netback this winter; moves toward the West Coast price once new capacity opens in March 2027 | 42¢ (Aug, reference price) |
| Ontario and Quebec | US Midwest and Northeast prices; Sarnia supply, rail and stocks | Follows the US |
Same Setup as 2015. More Than Twice the Price.
On paper this winter should be soft. NOAA’s 8 October update put the Niño-3.4 index at +2.1°C and gave a better than 83% chance of a strong to very strong El Niño through January–March, with a 70% chance it becomes a historic event. Verified Canada’s Centre for Climate Services expects a milder winter across much of the country, and notes that past very strong events warmed most east of the Rockies, through Ontario, Quebec and Atlantic Canada. Verified EIA expects US propane use in the Northeast to fall 10% this winter and household propane spending there to fall 15%. Verified
Why → In 2015 a surplus barrel had to find a home in North America, so the price fell until it did. Today the same barrel can go to Asia.
The difference is exports: 589 kb/d in mid-October 2015, 2,039 kb/d now. Verified In 2015–16 a surplus barrel had to find a home in North America, so the price fell until it did. Today it can be on a ship within days, and the price only has to match what Asia pays, less the trip. Interpretation
Record Barrels, Half the Cover
Why → A stock is only as large as what it has to serve. Exports have grown much faster than storage.
Stocks are 9% higher than in 2015. What they have to serve, US demand plus exports, has doubled. Measured in days, the US holds 35 days of propane against 65 in 2015 and 56 in 2016. Estimate
Nor is the record a glut. Last winter the export docks filled in March, spot dock fees jumped from 7.5¢ to 45¢ a gallon (Article 47), and stocks rose from 71.7 MMbbl on 6 March to 77.0 by month end, when they normally fall. Verified That left the highest end-of-winter level in EIA records back to 1994. Verified It changed in September. Stocks peaked at 110.5 MMbbl on 4 September and have fallen 4.6 MMbbl since; in each of the previous seven years they were still rising at this point. Verified The docks are no longer full, and Asian buyers are restocking for winter. Interpretation
The War Made the Gulf Coast the World’s Spare Tank
Why → Buyers that lost cargoes in the spring now pay for secure supply. That keeps North American barrels in demand even with tanks full.
The war explains why record stocks and high prices sit side by side. Closing the Strait of Hormuz removed more than 7 million tonnes of Middle East LPG, about 5% of seaborne supply, before a US–Iran deal in June began to reopen it. Reported Asian buyers turned to North America. The US share of China’s LPG imports rose from about 20% before the war to 56.5% in June, and India plans to take up to a quarter of its 2027 LPG imports from the US through a 2.75 Mt tender. Reported Canada sits on the short route: a West Coast cargo reaches North Asia in 10–11 days, against 25 or more from the US Gulf. Reported
The strait is not back to normal. Transits in September were the highest since the war began, but there have been at least 13 attacks on tankers and gas carriers since 28 September, a seven-month high. Reported Asian governments are adding to strategic oil reserves. Reported The same caution shapes LPG buying: a buyer that lost Middle East cargoes in the spring wants supply it can count on, and US and Canadian term cargoes are the safest available. Interpretation
That changes what US Gulf stocks are for. They are no longer just a buffer for the American winter but working stock for term cargoes to Asia, and the market’s insurance against another closure. Interpretation Normally high stocks mean a low price. High stocks and a high price together are the sign of a market paying to hold insurance. Interpretation The pull has limits: LPG-fed crackers in Northeast Asia were losing money in early October, so petrochemical buyers are cutting back (Article 47). Verified And the risk runs both ways. If a settlement holds and Middle East cargoes return, Asian prices fall first, Mont Belvieu follows, and the same stocks become a true surplus. Interpretation
The Surplus Is at the Docks
Why → Gulf storage is working stock for the export docks. The heating regions depend on pipelines and rail, and since 2014 one major pipeline into the Midwest has stopped carrying propane.
All of the increase on a year ago, and more, is on the Gulf Coast. Gulf stocks are up 5.0 MMbbl. The Midwest is down 1.9 MMbbl and the East Coast 0.4 MMbbl. Verified EIA counts 2.2 million Midwest households and 1.3 million in the Northeast that heat mainly with propane, and they burn the most per home: 641 and 515 gallons a winter, against 365 in the South. Verified
Gulf storage is working inventory for the export trade. Salt caverns at Mont Belvieu feed the docks on the Houston Ship Channel and at Beaumont, and much of what is stored there is waiting for a ship. Interpretation The heating regions depend on local gas plants, on pipelines and rail from the Gulf and on Canada. That supply has thinned before: in April 2014 the pipeline that carried Alberta propane into the US Midwest stopped carrying propane and was reversed to bring condensate into Alberta. Rail replaced it. Verified
Why → Each new dock gives Gulf barrels another way out, so more of Asia’s price reaches Texas.
The docks keep growing. Enterprise’s Neches River expansion entered service in May, able to load up to 360 kb/d of propane or 180 kb/d of ethane. Verified US propane exports reached a record 2.2 MMb/d in September on ship-tracking data, and the premium for loading a cargo at the Gulf over Mont Belvieu doubled from 5.3¢ to 10.8¢ a gallon. Reported Enterprise expects its Houston terminal to add about 300 kb/d of LPG export capacity by the end of 2026. Verified After that the next large additions are in 2028: a 400 kb/d terminal at Texas City and 55 kb/d more at Nederland. Reported
Why → With docks open, Mont Belvieu is set by what Asia pays less the trip, not by how much propane is in storage.
That is why record stocks have not made propane cheap. With docks open, a Gulf barrel is worth what Japan pays, less freight and the dock fee. Interpretation If VLGC rates fall, as a fleet growing 16% next year suggests they will, or new docks push loading fees down, Mont Belvieu rises even if US stocks do not move. Reported Interpretation The main relief for a heating customer this winter is a weaker Asian price, not a bigger US inventory. Interpretation
The New Docks Decide the Winter
Our US balance runs from 16 October to 31 March. Production holds at 2,900 kb/d (2,889 today, 66 kb/d above a year ago). Imports, mostly from Canada, run at 130 kb/d. Demand is 1,250 kb/d in a normal winter, the average of the last three, 5% less if mild and 10% more if cold. Exports stay near today’s 2,050 kb/d or average 2,200 kb/d as the Houston expansion ramps up from January. Estimate
Why → Last winter full docks held exports back. This winter there is more dock capacity, so weather and docks together decide the draw.
A mild winter with today’s docks ends March at 74 MMbbl, well above the five-year average of 52.5: the surplus survives. A normal winter with the new Houston docks ends at 36, close to the lowest end-of-winter level since 2015. Estimate A cold winter with the new docks ends at 14, less than half the lowest end-of-winter level since 2015. That case will not happen as modelled. Before stocks fall that far, Mont Belvieu rises until exports slow, and North American buyers outbid Asia for the barrels they need. Interpretation The danger in a cold winter is not that propane runs out. It is that the domestic price has to rise to the export price, and in the Midwest above it. Interpretation
Canada matters to this balance too. Most US propane imports come from Canada, and our model holds them at 130 kb/d. From March, when the new West Coast terminal opens, more Western barrels go to Asia and fewer need to come south. That tightens the US balance just as winter ends. Interpretation
El Niño Lowers the Odds. It Does Not Remove the Risk.
Why → A strong El Niño lowers the odds of a hard winter. It does not remove cold snaps, and the Midwest is starting lower than last year.
The Midwest starts this winter with 26.1 MMbbl, 1.9 MMbbl less than a year ago. If it draws like each of the last 21 winters, it bottoms between 5.3 and 16.8 MMbbl, with a median of 9.8. Estimate In 3 of the 21 cases it falls below 7.2 MMbbl, the low of the 2013–14 shortage. Estimate That winter is worth remembering. In October 2013 Midwest wholesale propane was 122¢ a gallon, exactly where it is this week. By 27 January 2014 it was 399¢, while Mont Belvieu peaked at 170¢. Verified
El Niño helps on average. Drawn like 2015–16 the Midwest would bottom at 13.0 MMbbl; like 2023–24, at 10.6. Estimate But 2009–10 was also an El Niño winter, and it drew the Midwest harder than any winter in the past two decades. Repeated this year, it would leave 5.3 MMbbl, the lowest result of all. Estimate El Niño shifts the average. It does not stop a two-week Arctic outbreak, and in an outbreak only local stocks can respond within days. Gulf barrels take longer to move north, and this year they have to outbid a ship to do it. Interpretation
Western Canada: Long This Winter, Shorter From March
Why → The West is long and its exits are full until new export capacity opens. The East relies on Line 5, rail and US supply.
Western Canada has been long all year. Its propane inventories were above the year before in every month the CER has reported in 2026, by 3–34%, and stood at 6.82 MMbbl on 1 August, 26% higher than a year earlier. Verified Part of that is a low base, since Western stocks entered last winter 12.6% below their five-year average. Verified But the build is real, for three reasons.
First, supply keeps growing. Alberta produces 273 kb/d of propane and uses 94 kb/d, so two-thirds has to leave the province (Article 47), and S&P Global expects Canadian propane exports to rise from 230 kb/d in 2025 to 244 kb/d in 2026. Verified Reported Second, the exits are full. Canada sent 126 kb/d to the US, mostly by rail, and 108 kb/d overseas from the West Coast in January–July, where the largest exporter reported record volumes in the second quarter. Verified Reported Third, new capacity is late. A 56 kb/d West Coast LPG export terminal that was due by the end of 2026 is now expected in March 2027, after building its jetty lost more than 450 rig days to weather and ocean swells. Reported Barrels that would have gone overseas this winter stay in Western storage until it opens, and some stock will be held to commission the terminal and load its first cargoes. Interpretation
Why → Once it opens, Western barrels get a second large exit. Western stocks stop building and the US loses some of its Canadian supply.
The new terminal changes the West’s balance in 2027. With a further 30 kb/d propane expansion due in the second half of the year, overseas capacity could rise from 108 kb/d to about 194 kb/d within a year, up to 80% more. Estimate At 56 kb/d, the first terminal alone would export about 20 MMbbl a year, three times Western stocks on 1 August. Estimate Once it runs, Western stocks should stop building, and Alberta’s price should move up toward the West Coast export netback, which S&P Global estimated pays about $5/bbl more than sending propane south to Conway. Reported Interpretation The effect crosses the border. Fewer Western barrels will need to go south by rail, so the US Midwest and Eastern Canada will compete with Asian buyers for Western propane as well as Gulf propane. Interpretation
This winter, though, the West is long, the Prairies should be mild and the new exit is months away. Interpretation Alberta’s propane reference price was 42¢ a gallon in August, 61% of Mont Belvieu and 21% of WTI, and Edmonton spot was about 68¢ in early October (Article 47). Verified Estimate Expect the discount to the US to stay wide until March, then narrow. Interpretation The floor is higher than in 2015, when Western stocks hit records and Edmonton propane touched 3¢ a gallon a year after the Midwest pipeline was reversed. Verified The West Coast route, open since 2019, did not exist then. Interpretation
Eastern Canada: Lean, and Tied to the US
Eastern Canada is where the Canadian winter risk sits. Ontario entered last winter with stocks 30.6% below their five-year average. Verified On 1 August Eastern Canada held 2.59 MMbbl, 5% more than a year earlier, after running below the year before in four of the seven months reported (Fig. 9). Verified Ontario accounted for more than half of Canadian residential propane demand in the CER’s last review, though industry, commercial users and farms take most of the volume. Verified
Supply comes three ways: the propane-rich mix Enbridge’s Line 5 carries to Sarnia, rail from the West and small US imports, with salt caverns at Sarnia and Windsor holding the winter stock. Verified Each route has a winter weakness. Rail, the flexible supply, is limited by tank cars and cold-weather reliability. Verified US imports come from the same Midwest and Northeast markets that are short themselves this year. Interpretation In 2013–14 Sarnia wholesale prices rose 166% between June and February, and deliveries ran short in eastern Ontario and western Quebec. Verified
Two things protect the East this winter. The strongest El Niño warming is expected over Ontario, Quebec and Atlantic Canada, and the West has more propane to send. Interpretation From March, though, the West Coast starts bidding for the same Western barrels. The East pays what the US Midwest and Northeast pay; the West gets the export price less transport. Interpretation The gap between them is the value of rail cars, storage and contracts that move Western barrels east before January. Interpretation
Distributors Are Absorbing the Rise
Why → Retail prices lag, and many customers bought fixed-price winter supply in the summer. Until retail catches up, distributors absorb the difference.
US wholesale propane was 124¢ a gallon in the week of 19 October, up 57% on a year ago. The residential price was 269¢, up 11%. Verified The gap between them, which pays for delivery, tanks, staff and margin, has narrowed by 19¢ nationally and by 24¢ in the Midwest. Estimate Retail prices lag wholesale, and many customers locked in fixed-price winter supply during the summer, when Mont Belvieu was 69–76¢. Distributors that hedged keep their margin; those that did not absorb the difference. Interpretation EIA expects lower household propane bills this winter because of milder weather. Verified For distributors that means lower volumes at the same time as thinner margins. Interpretation
The money is going to whoever owns the route out of the Gulf. The dock premium doubled in September. VLGC freight takes 57–66¢ of every gallon delivered to Japan. Mont Belvieu is up 83% on a year ago, so US producers selling there are taking most of the rise. Verified Interpretation Western Canadian sellers get the export price less transport. Midwest and Eastern customers carry the risk of a cold snap. Interpretation
Hold Barrels Where They Burn
US Midwest and Northeast distributor
Do Secure December–February supply now, as close to customers as you can. In a cold snap only local barrels arrive within days.
Secure Pricing indexed to where you take delivery, and storage or rail you control.
Eastern Canadian distributor
Do Fill storage before December and keep Western rail supply moving while the West is long.
Secure More than one route: Sarnia, rail from Alberta and US imports.
Western Canadian producer or midstream
Do The West is long until the new West Coast terminal opens in March, and a mild Prairie winter adds to it. Price winter barrels for storage, not for export.
Secure Rail cars and storage for this winter, and West Coast export space for 2027 before the new capacity is spoken for.
US Gulf exporter or storage owner
Do You hold the scarce link. The dock premium doubled to 10.8¢ in September.
Secure Term dock contracts before Enterprise’s Houston expansion and the 2028 terminals bring fees down.
Trader or marketer
Do Watch the Midwest and Alberta spreads to Mont Belvieu, not the price level. Both move before the Gulf can respond.
Secure Optionality: storage near demand, pipeline space north, rail.
Signposts to watch
| Signal | Now | Watch for | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Midwest stocks (EIA, weekly) | 26.1 MMbbl, -2% vs average | More than 3 MMbbl below the five-year average before January | The heating buffer is thinning before the coldest weeks |
| Gulf dock premium to Mont Belvieu | 10.8¢/gal (Sep) | Back above 20¢ | Docks are full again: Gulf barrels stay home and domestic prices ease |
| Enterprise Houston expansion | Due by end-2026 | Start-up date and first cargoes | About 300 kb/d more pull on Gulf stocks from January |
| Mont Belvieu vs Japan less the trip | About level (Fig. 6) | Mont Belvieu well below the netback | Exports are slowing, leaving more for North American buyers |
| Weather (NOAA, ECCC) | El Niño Advisory; Niño-3.4 +2.1°C | The first Arctic outbreak in the Midwest or Ontario | The real test of Fig. 8 |
| Eastern Canada stocks (CER) | 2.59 MMbbl (1 Aug) | 1 November and 1 December reports | Whether the East has caught up before winter |
| New West Coast LPG terminal | Due March 2027 | First cargoes, or a further delay | Western stocks start to draw and Alberta’s discount narrows |
| Hormuz | Transits at a wartime high; 13 attacks since 28 Sep | A durable settlement, or a new closure | A settlement cuts Asian prices and Mont Belvieu; a closure lifts both |
The honest objection
A strong El Niño, or a lasting peace in the Gulf, may make all of this academic. NOAA puts the odds of a strong to very strong El Niño through March above 83%, and EIA expects Northeast propane use to fall 10%. A settlement that brings Middle East cargoes back would cut Asian prices, and Mont Belvieu with them. Both are fair. But El Niño changes the odds, not the extremes: 2009–10 was an El Niño winter too. And a cheaper Asian price would change what propane costs, not where it sits. The Midwest, the East Coast and Eastern Canada would still start the winter with less than normal.
What would prove this wrong
- US stocks end March above 60 MMbbl after a normal winter with the new Houston capacity running.
- Midwest wholesale propane trades below Mont Belvieu for several weeks this winter.
- Mont Belvieu falls below 80¢ while delivered-Japan propane holds above $900/t.
- Eastern Canada’s inventories reach their five-year average by 1 December.
- Western Canada’s stocks fall below last year’s level before the new West Coast terminal opens.
The United States has never had more propane going into a winter, or so many ways to send it abroad, and Western Canada is about to gain another. This winter the weather decides how much propane the continent burns. The docks decide what it costs: every gallon in a Midwest or Ontario tank is priced against what a ship to Asia would pay for it.
Insight Stream — LNG/LPG & Waterborne Trade Analysis
LNG contract economics, LPG benchmarks and Pacific trade flows, VLGC freight, China PDH and NGL export infrastructure. Independent market intelligence, built only on sources you can check.



