51%of LNG trades now linked to physical gas hubs — surpassing oil-indexed for the first time in 2024 (Energy Risk, November 2025)
USD 1.68Structural feedgas cost advantage of AECO over Henry Hub for Pacific Basin LNG (2026 forecast) — before the formula is even negotiated
17.2%The oil parity ceiling — the maximum possible JCC slope, equivalent to pricing LNG at oil’s energy value. Sellers rarely get here; buyers always know the limit.

Every LNG negotiation eventually reaches the point where two numbers matter more than anything else: the index and the slope. These are the mechanics of the pricing formula — the contractual structure that determines whether a buyer pays USD 8 or USD 12 per MMBtu for the same molecule, and whether a seller captures or surrenders the value their project was built to generate. The formula is not a footnote to the commercial negotiation. It is the commercial negotiation.

Most sellers spend their energy on volume, tenure, and logistics. Sophisticated buyers come to the table having already mapped every formula scenario: what price they pay if Brent goes to USD 100, what they pay if Henry Hub goes to USD 5, where the ceiling is on an oil-indexed deal, and at what JKM level a hub-linked contract becomes more expensive than spot. Sellers who have not done this work are negotiating blind against counterparties who have.

This article explains the mechanics of LNG pricing formulas, why the market is shifting from oil to hub-linked pricing, what is currently happening to the cost of Henry Hub-indexed contracts, and what the formula picture means specifically for Pacific Basin LNG sellers in the current market.

The market that changed: from oil-indexed to hub-linked

LNG pricing was born oil-indexed. When Japan began importing LNG in the 1970s, no global gas price benchmark existed. The solution was to link LNG prices to crude oil — specifically, to the Japan Customs-Cleared Crude Oil Price, known as the Japanese Crude Cocktail or JCC. The JCC formula became the foundation of virtually all Asian LNG contracts for four decades.

The structural shift: hub-linked LNG pricing surpassed oil-indexed for the first time in 2024Share of global LNG trades by pricing mechanism  ·  from under 15pct in 2005 to 51pct today
Pricing shift chart
Sources: Energy Risk (November 2025): “There has been a major shift in LNG pricing, with 51% of trades now linked to physical gas hubs, up from under 15% in 2005.” Global LNG Hub (June 2025): “The share of hub-based LNG pricing rose to over 50% for the very first time in 2024.” EIA (March 2026): 56% of 2025 US LNG contracts confirmed Henry Hub-indexed, down from 67% in 2024. US LNG now exceeds 20% of global LNG trade. Historical trajectory interpolated between confirmed data points. F = forecast.

Two forces drove the shift. First, the United States became the world’s largest LNG exporter — growing from zero in 2015 to more than 126 billion cubic metres exported in 2024, representing over 20% of global LNG trade (Energy Risk, November 2025). US LNG contracts are almost entirely Henry Hub-linked, because US producers price their feedgas at Henry Hub and build contracts that pass that exposure to buyers. Second, the spot market grew from less than 10% of global LNG trade in the early 2000s to over 30% by recent years (Global LNG Hub, June 2025) — and spot deals are typically priced against live benchmarks rather than oil formulas.

The consequence: the market that buyers and sellers are negotiating in today is structurally different from the one that defined LNG pricing for the first thirty years of the industry. Understanding both formula types — oil-indexed and hub-linked — is no longer optional for a commercial team on either side of the table.

How the formulas actually work

Oil-indexed (JCC / Brent) formula
PLNG = a × JCC + b
Where: a = the slope (typically 10–16% of Brent; current market ~12%); b = constant (covers freight, inflation adjustments, or premium/discount)
Maximum theoretical slope: 17.2% — the oil energy parity ceiling (crude has a 5.8-to-1 heating value equivalent to gas; reciprocal = 17.2%)
Source: Columbia University CGEP (May 2025); NGI glossary; Poten & Partners via USAEE
Henry Hub-indexed formula (US LNG)
PLNG = 115% × HH + USD 3.00 (FOB)   |   119–121% × HH + USD 4.00–4.50 (DES Asia)
FOB: buyer takes title at loading terminal; pays 115% of Henry Hub plus a liquefaction fee of at least USD 2.75–3.00/MMBtu
DES to Asia: slope 119–121% with a constant factor covering liquefaction and freight; constant has moved from ~USD 4.50 to ~USD 4.00/MMBtu on average (reflecting weaker freight expectations)
Source: Argus Media (December 2025); NGI (January 2026) citing Spark Commodities; S&P Global Commodity Insights (May 2024)

The slope is the most negotiated variable in any LNG SPA. In an oil-indexed deal, the slope determines how much of every dollar of oil price movement passes through to the gas buyer. At 12% and Brent at USD 80/barrel, LNG costs USD 9.60/MMBtu. At 14% and the same oil price, it costs USD 11.20/MMBtu — a USD 1.60 difference on the same cargo. Across a 5 MTPA contract over five years, that difference represents approximately USD 1.8 billion. As Timera Energy (a specialist LNG contract analytics firm) notes: “a 10 cent per MMBtu shift in contract price across a 5-year 5 MTPA deal impacts value by around USD 140 million.” A 1% slope shift is not a minor adjustment. It is a multi-hundred-million-dollar decision.

The pricing formula made visible: what JCC/Brent and Henry Hub contracts deliver at different benchmark levelsUSD/MMBtu  ·  left panel = oil-indexed; right panel = HH-indexed FOB and DES
Formula comparison
Sources: JCC slopes: Columbia University CGEP (May 2025): “A typical slope will range between 10 and 16% of Brent crude.” Current contracts ~12% per Poten & Partners/USAEE. Oil parity ceiling: 17.2% per NGI glossary. HH FOB formula: 115% × HH + USD 3/MMBtu per Argus Media (December 2025): “The indicative long-term LNG contract price — 115% of Henry Hub plus a USD 3/mn Btu liquefaction fee.” HH DES formula: S&P Global Commodity Insights (May 2024): Asian buyers signing DES contracts “have negotiated contract slopes ranging between 119% and 121%” with constant USD 4–4.5/MMBtu. USD 4.25 used as midpoint.

The Henry Hub trap: what Japan just signed and what it will cost

In 2025, Japanese companies signed 7.5 MTPA of new LNG contracts with US exporters. These contracts are indexed to Henry Hub (IEEFA, March 2026). At the time of signing, Henry Hub had averaged just USD 2.19/MMBtu in 2024. The math looked straightforward: 115% × USD 2.19 + USD 3.00 liquefaction = USD 5.52/MMBtu FOB, plus shipping — comfortably below spot JKM. Buyers were locking in supply security at a price that seemed commercially attractive against a backdrop of USD 10–12 JKM spot.

The picture is now more complex. The EIA forecasts Henry Hub rising from USD 3.53/MMBtu in 2025 to nearly USD 4.40/MMBtu in 2027. IEEFA (March 2026) notes that HH is “expected to average USD 5/MMBtu over the next five years.” NGI (January 2026) reported that by October 2026, according to Spark Commodities forward shipping data, variable costs and shipping fees on HH-linked US LNG could push the delivered cost to Asia above JKM. In that scenario, buyers who signed HH-linked contracts in 2024–2025 at USD 2.19 HH will be paying above spot rates in 2026–2028.

Henry Hub is rising — and what it means for the delivered cost of HH-linked LNG contracted to AsiaUSD/MMBtu  ·  red = delivered HH-linked cost; orange = JKM spot; dark = HH benchmark
HH trajectory
Sources: Henry Hub actuals: EIA (2022: USD 6.45; 2023: USD 2.74; 2024: USD 2.19/MMBtu per IEEFA March 2026). Forecasts: EIA STEO via CAPP (Oct 2025): USD 4.03/MMBtu 2026F; EIA via IEEFA (Mar 2026): USD 4.40/MMBtu 2027F; IEEFA expectation USD 5/MMBtu 5-year avg. Delivered formula: 115% × HH + USD 3.00 liquefaction + USD 1.50 shipping per Argus Media (Dec 2025) and NGI (Jan 2026). JKM: approximate from Kpler (Jan 2026) and NGI. NGI (Jan 2026) citing Spark Commodities: “By October 2026, variable costs and shipping fees could push contracted LNG above JKM.” F = forecast.
Live commercial risk — Japan, 2025
“In 2025, Japanese companies signed 7.5 million tonnes per annum worth of new LNG contracts with US companies. These contracts are indexed to Henry Hub prices, which are expected to average USD 5/MMBtu over the next five years, up from USD 2.19/MMBtu in 2024. A similar dynamic is already emerging following the conflict in Iran that began in late February 2026. Since the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, the Japan-Korea Marker has doubled.”
Source: IEEFA, “Japan’s diversified LNG procurement strategy cannot fully shield it from global price spikes” (March 2026).

This is not a criticism of the buyers who signed those contracts. Supply security from a non-Hormuz source was a legitimate priority, and at the time of signing the HH formula looked advantageous. It is an illustration of the fundamental commercial risk embedded in hub-linked contracts: the seller’s feedgas cost determines the buyer’s purchase price, regardless of what is happening to delivered LNG market values. The formula disconnects the buyer from spot market signals. When HH was low, this was the buyer’s advantage. As HH rises, it becomes the buyer’s exposure.

What buyers attack in the negotiating room

Experienced LNG buyers who understand pricing formulas come to negotiations having modelled four specific points of attack. Sellers who have not pre-modelled these will concede value they did not know they were surrendering.

Four formula attack points that buyers use — and how sellers should prepare
01
The slope level
Every percentage point of JCC slope at Brent USD 80/bbl is worth USD 0.80/MMBtu. Buyers know the current market range (10–16%) and they know the ceiling (17.2%). They will push slope down by citing supply abundance, buyer bargaining power, and competing seller proposals. Sellers without a robust slope floor backed by project economics will give ground. A 10-cent move per MMBtu across a 5 MTPA deal over 5 years is approximately USD 140 million in value transfer (Timera Energy).
02
The S-curve floor and ceiling
Legacy JCC contracts often contained S-curve price adjustment mechanisms: the slope changed at defined oil price levels, capping the buyer’s cost at high oil prices and protecting the seller at low oil prices. Most modern contracts have moved to straight-line (linear) formulas, but buyers still negotiate for implicit or explicit caps and floors. A seller who agrees to a floor without modelling what happens at USD 50 Brent has given away optionality worth hundreds of millions over a 15-year contract.
03
The index choice itself
In an oversupplied market with rising Henry Hub, a sophisticated buyer may push for JKM linkage instead of HH or JCC. JKM represents the buyer’s actual alternative: the spot market in their region. A JKM-linked contract transfers price risk back to the seller and converts the SPA into a basis-risk instrument rather than a fixed-formula purchase. Most sellers resist JKM linkage because it removes cost certainty for project finance. The fact that buyers ask for it reveals their real preference: delivered cost that tracks their market.
04
The constant (the “b” in the formula)
The constant covers freight, inflation adjustments, and other fixed cost components. In DES Asian contracts, this constant has moved from approximately USD 4.50/MMBtu to USD 4.00/MMBtu on average, reflecting falling freight expectations (S&P Global, May 2024). Buyers benchmark the constant against current shipping markets and CPI inflation adjustors. A constant that was fair in 2022 may overprice freight by 2026. Sellers who locked in high constants in a seller’s market may find buyers seeking reopeners when freight rates normalize.

The formula advantage Pacific Basin sellers should be building

Here is the structural commercial point that most Canadian LNG sellers are not yet leading with in pricing discussions: the feedgas cost advantage embedded in AECO pricing creates a formula advantage that is real, quantifiable, and currently around USD 1.68/MMBtu at the wellhead versus Henry Hub.

The Canadian feedgas pricing advantage: AECO vs Henry Hub for Pacific LNG economics (2026 forecast)USD/MMBtu benchmark  ·  AECO structural discount creates lower FOB cost before formula is even negotiated
Canada pricing advantage
Sources: AECO 2026F: NGI Forward Look — NOVA/AECO C average C$2.93/GJ (~USD 2.35/MMBtu) per CAPP Natural Gas Market Fundamentals (October 2025). Henry Hub 2026F: USD 4.03/MMBtu per CAPP/EIA STEO (October 2025). AECO basis confirmed: NGI Forward Look (January 2026): minus USD 1.36–1.48/MMBtu vs HH; Morningstar/NGI (February 2026): AECO averaging C$2.50/Mcf in 2026. FOB formula: 115% × hub price + USD 3.00/MMBtu per Argus Media (December 2025). FX: approx USD 0.74 per C$1. Advantage is structural at feedgas level — liquefaction capital costs, pipeline tolls, and shipping are additional and determined by project.

A Pacific Coast Canadian LNG seller pricing feedgas off AECO at USD 2.35/MMBtu starts with a FOB cost of approximately USD 5.70/MMBtu (115% × USD 2.35 + USD 3.00 liquefaction). A US Gulf Coast seller pricing off HH at USD 4.03/MMBtu starts at approximately USD 7.63/MMBtu FOB. The structural gap is USD 1.93/MMBtu FOB before shipping and before formula negotiation. Because Pacific Coast shipping to Japan is also shorter than USGC–Japan routes, the delivered cost advantage is potentially larger still. As IndexBox (June 2025) noted of LNG Canada’s positioning: “The AECO Storage Hub price was recently recorded at 96.6 Canadian cents per MMBtu, significantly lower than the Henry Hub futures price of USD 3.746 per MMBtu. This pricing structure, coupled with the project’s proximity to Asia, enhances its attractiveness.”

The formula implication is direct. A Pacific Basin Canadian seller can offer a buyer either: an AECO-linked formula that gives the buyer a lower-cost, geopolitically stable non-Hormuz supply; or a JCC-linked deal that competes with Qatari and Australian supply on familiar terms. The AECO basis creates competitive room to offer a more attractive slope on oil-indexed terms or a lower constant on hub-indexed terms — because the underlying feedgas cost structure is more competitive than the USGC alternative.

~USD 5.70
Indicative FOB cost of AECO-based Canadian LNG (115% × USD 2.35 + USD 3.00 liq) — 2026 estimate using confirmed formula structure
~USD 7.63
Indicative FOB cost of HH-linked US Gulf Coast LNG (115% × USD 4.03 + USD 3.00 liq) — 2026 estimate same formula
USD 1.93
Structural FOB cost advantage of Canadian AECO-based LNG vs USGC HH-based LNG at 2026 forecast hub prices — before shipping differential

What a formula-literate seller looks like in the room

The seller who understands pricing formulas walks into the SPA negotiation having already done three things that most sellers have not. First, they have modelled the formula under every benchmark scenario the buyer will run: Brent at USD 60, 80, 100, and 120/bbl; HH at USD 2, 3, 4, and 5/MMBtu. They know where their contract is in the money, out of the money, and at what level the buyer will want to reopen. Second, they have identified the terms they will trade: they might concede slope flexibility for a longer duration, or offer a lower constant in exchange for take-or-pay certainty. Third, they understand what the buyer’s real alternative is — not just JKM spot, but the full spectrum of competing supply the buyer is also evaluating — and they have priced their formula relative to that competitive set, not just relative to their own cost structure.

The formula is not the last agenda item of an SPA negotiation. It is the first question a buyer’s commercial team has already answered internally before the first meeting takes place. Sellers who treat the formula as a technical appendix to the volume discussion will find that they have been negotiating the wrong thing.

“The slope, the index, and the constant are not contractual boilerplate. They are the decisions that determine whether a project creates or destroys value over its 20-year life. Every basis point of slope, every dollar of constant, and every index choice is a permanent allocation of commercial risk between two parties with opposing interests. Buyers understand this. Sellers who do not are giving away value before the negotiation has begun.”

IS

Insight Stream — LNG/LPG & Waterborne Trade Analysis

LNG contract economics, LPG benchmarks and Pacific trade flows, VLGC freight, China PDH and NGL export infrastructure. Independent market intelligence, built only on sources you can check.

Read More →